Maryland case law › Agnoli v. Powers, Assignees

Agnoli v. Powers, Assignees

235 Md. 289 (1964) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DismissedHorney, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case came before the Court of Appeals of Maryland on an appeal from a judgment of the Circuit Court for Baltimore County. The appellees, Powers, Assignees, filed a motion to dismiss the appeal under Maryland Rule 835 b, which was denied as untimely. The appellees then renewed the motion in their brief. The majority of the Court of Appeals dismissed the appeal, holding that the record was not transmitted within the time prescribed by Maryland Rule 825 a and that dismissal was proper under Rule 835 b(4). Judge Horney, joined by Judge Sybert, dissented. The dissent agreed that Rule 825 a limits the time for transmitting the record and that Rule 835 b(4) permits dismissal for failure to transmit timely, but disagreed on the effect of Rule 836. The dissent argued that Rule 836 provides two optional methods for filing a motion to dismiss: either within ten days after the record is filed (
Questions presented
  • Whether an appellee who files a motion to dismiss an appeal under Maryland Rule 836 c, which is denied because it was not filed seasonably, may renew the motion by including it in his brief under Rule 836 d.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Horney, J., filed the following dissenting opinion, in which Sybert, J., concurred. We agree that Maryland Rule 825 a limits the time for transmitting the record to this Court unless a different time is fixed pursuant to section b and c and that this Court may dismiss an appeal under Rule 835 b (4) if the record is not transmitted within the time prescribed. But we do not agree as to the effect of Rule 836 regulating the filing of a motion to dismiss an appeal under 835 b. While a motion may be filed either within ten days from the date the record is filed with this Court pursuant to 836 c or the motion may be included in the appellees’ brief pursuant to Rule 836 d, the rule clearly does not authorize an appellee who files a motion under section c, which is denied because it was not filed seasonably, to renew the motion by including it in his brief.

The method the appellee may use is optional, Bornstein v. State Tax Commission, 295 227 Md. 331 , 176 A. 2d 859 (1962), which means he may choose one or the other, but he may not use both. Under the circumstances in this case, the appeal should have been decided on its merits. Judge Sybert joins me in dissenting.