Maryland case law › Allen v. State

Allen v. State

230 Md. 533 (1963) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThe defendant was convicted of first degree murder without capital punishment and sentenced to life imprisonment after a bench trial. He appealed, contending that he and the deceased had been drinking heavily on the night of the shooting, rendering him incapable of the premeditation required for first degree murder. The evidence showed that the defendant and the deceased exchanged words earlier at a tavern; the defendant left, went home, obtained a small pistol, returned to the tavern, called the deceased outside, shot him twice, then went home and to bed. The defendant also presented evidence that he was an epileptic and claimed self-defense. The trial judge, relying on a medical report, found that epilepsy played no primary role in the affair and that the defendant was mentally responsible. The judge also considered and rejected the self-defense claim. On appeal, the Court of Appeals f
Questions presented
  • Whether the defendant's heavy drinking on the night of the shooting rendered him incapable of the premeditation required for first degree murder.
  • Whether the trial court erred in rejecting the defense of self-defense.
  • Whether the trial court erred in finding that epilepsy played no primary role and that the defendant was mentally responsible.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

PER Curiam. The defendant appeals from a conviction of first degree murder, without capital punishment, and the sentence of life imprisonment prescribed therefor by statute. He contends that he, as well as the deceased, had been drinking heavily on the night of the shooting and that he was consequently incapable of the premeditation which must be proven in order to sustain a charge of first degree murder. There is evidence that the defendant and the deceased had had some words earlier in the evening while they were at a tavern, that the defendant left, went to his home, got a small pistol, returned to the tavern, called the deceased outside and shot him twice, and then went home and to bed.

The defendant showed that he was an epileptic and he also claimed that he acted in self-defense. The trial judge, before whom the defendant was tried without a jury, found on the basis of a medical report that epilepsy played no primary role in the affair and that the defendant was mentally responsible. He also considered and rejected the defense of self-defense. We find no basis upon which to overturn his findings of fact.

In Armstead v. State, 227 Md. 73 , 175 A. 2d 24 , which was also a first degree murder case in which the defendant suffered from epilepsy and had been drinking heavily, this court refused to adopt the so-called diminished responsibility rule. We think that the Armstead case is controlling here. Judgment affirmed.