Maryland case law › Attorney Grievance Commission v. McCloskey

Attorney Grievance Commission v. McCloskey

306 Md. 677 (1986) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: OtherEldridge✓ Good law
SummaryThis case is before the Court of Appeals of Maryland on a disciplinary proceeding against attorney John R. McCloskey. The trial court found that Bar Counsel had not shown any previous complaints or grievances against McCloskey, that McCloskey was remorseful, completely candid in testifying, and cooperated with Bar Counsel. Most significantly, the trial court found that McCloskey's predicament resulted from poor judgment rather than any willful intent to violate the Canons of Professional Responsibility. Bar Counsel took no exception to these findings. The majority of the Court of Appeals ordered disbarment. Judge Eldridge dissented, stating that in light of the trial court's findings, he would impose a substantial suspension instead of disbarment. The dissent emphasized the trial court's findings of remorse, candor, cooperation, and lack of willful intent, and noted that Bar Counsel did
Questions presented
  • Whether, in light of the trial court's findings of remorse, candor, cooperation, and lack of willful intent, the appropriate sanction is disbarment or a substantial suspension.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

ELDRIDGE, Judge, dissenting: The trial court in this case found that Bar Counsel had not shown “that there had been any previous complaints or grievances filed against the Defendant.” The court also pointed out that the “demeanor of the Defendant before the Court was that of a remorseful person.” The trial court went on to find that Mr. McCloskey “was completely candid in testifying before the Court” and cooperated with Bar Counsel. Most significantly, the trial court found “that Mr. McCloskey has put himself in the predicament that he now finds himself because of poor judgment 691 rather than any willful intent to violate the Canons of Professional Responsibility.” Bar counsel has taken no exception to these findings. In light of the trial court’s findings in this case, I would impose a substantial suspension instead of disbarment.