Maryland case law › Baltimore Commercial Bank v. Shapiro

Baltimore Commercial Bank v. Shapiro

141 Md. 563 (1922) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedStockbridge, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case is a companion to No. 14, argued at the same term, and involves a suit by the holder of a trade acceptance against the makers. The case was tried on the same testimony as No. 14, and the facts are fully stated in the opinion in that case. The Court found it unnecessary to add anything to the views expressed in No. 14, except with regard to the particular prayers offered in this case. The Court held that the lower court's refusal of the plaintiff's prayers was correct because those prayers were based entirely upon the cancellation of the certification in question without submitting, under proper instructions, the question of the propriety or right of cancellation by the certifying bank. The Court reasoned that by such certification, unless a right of cancellation existed and was exercised in accordance with such right, the maker and endorsers of the instrument were released from
Questions presented
  • Whether the lower court erred in refusing the plaintiff's prayers which were based entirely upon the cancellation of the certification without submitting the question of the propriety or right of cancellation by the certifying bank.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

564 Stockbridgke, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. This case is a companion to Ho. 14 (ante, p.554) argued at this term, and is a suit brought by the holder of the trade acceptance referred to in that case against the makers. The case was tried on the same testimony as in Ho. 14, and the facts are fully stated in the opinion in that case. It is not necessary to add anything’ to the views therein expressed, except, with regard to the particular prayers offered in this case.

We are of the opinion that the action of the lower court in refusing the plaintiff’s prayers was correct, in that they are based entirely upon the cancellation of the certification in question without srubmitting, under proper instructions, the question of the propriety or right of cancellation by the certifying bank, since by such certification, unless a right of cancellation existed and was exercised in accordance with such right, the maker and endorsers of such instrument were released from all...liability thereon. Code,’art. 13, sec. 207; Scheffenacker v. Hoopes, 113 Md. 117 . The judgment of the lower court is accordingly affirmed. Judgment affirmed, with costs.

Araaire, J., dissents.