Maryland case law › Baltimore & Ohio Railroad v. Brady

Baltimore & Ohio Railroad v. Brady

32 Md. 333 (1870) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedBrent, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis was an action by Brady (appellee) against the Baltimore & Ohio Railroad (appellant) to recover for the loss of cattle transported by the railroad. The railroad attempted to limit its common-carrier liability by showing that Brady paid a special tariff rate under which, by the company's printed table, the company assumed no responsibility for loss, damage, or delay of stock. The Court, per Brent, J., held that a common carrier may limit its ordinary responsibilities by express contract, but the burden of proving such a contract is on the carrier. To establish the special contract, the carrier must show that the owner had notice or actual knowledge of the terms at or before delivery of the stock and that he assented to them. Payment of the special rate alone does not, as a matter of law, establish notice or assent; it is a question of fact for the jury. The Court found that the eviden
Questions presented
  • Whether a common carrier can limit its ordinary liability by an express contract, and if so, upon whom does the burden of proof rest to establish such a contract?
  • Whether payment of a special tariff rate, under which the carrier's printed table disclaims responsibility for loss, damage, or delay of stock, is sufficient to establish a special contract limiting liability, absent proof that the owner had notice or knowledge of the terms and assented to them?
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Brent, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. There is no doubt that a common carrier, by an express contract with his employer, may limit his ordinary responsibilities. Where indemnity from loss is claimed by virtue of such a contract, the burden of proof to establish it is upon the carrier. In this case, a special contract was attempted to be set up by showing, that the appellee paid for the transportation of his stock at a tariff of charges under which, by the printed table, the company assumed no responsibility for loss, damage or delay of stock.

This alone was not sufficient. It was necessary to show that the owner of the cattle had notice' or actual knowledge of these terms at the time or before the 339 delivery of the stock by him to the company, to be transported, and that they were assented to on his part. 2 Redfield on R. W., 80. This was the only question in the case. It was one of fact for the jury upon all the evidence, and was properly submitted to them.

(Decided 10th March, 1870.) There was no written contract offered which the Court was called upon to construe, and although the appellee may have paid the special rates, it docs not follow, as a conclusion of law, that he had notice of the terms upon which they were charged, or that he assented to the same. The weight of testimony is against any such conclusion. The evidence offered by the company shows that really no contract was entered into by the appellee to limit their responsibility as a common carrier. Where the special rates were accepted, releases were to be given.

In this case, no release was given by the owner of the cattle, and according to the company’s own terms, a contract was never consummated between the parties. Their own evidence also rebuts the presumption of any contract growing out of the charge of the special rates. The cattle were placed on the cars at Brady’s Mills, and the charges made for their transportation were fixed at the company’s office in Baltimore city, after the accident and loss occurred, upon which this action is founded. In looking at the whole case, the appellant has nothing to complain of in the instructions and prayers which were granted by the Court below.

The prayers of the appellee, which were granted, properly state the law of the case. And in the fourth prayer of the appellant, the case is most favorably submitted to the jury upon the law, and the whole question of the existence of any special contract left to be passed upon by them on the whole evidence in the case. Seeing no error in the rulings of the Court below, the judgment will be affirmed. Judgment affirmed.