Maryland case law › Bell v. Warden

Bell v. Warden

215 Md. 614 (1957) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DeniedHorney, J.✓ Good law
SummaryWilliam R. Bell was convicted in the Criminal Court of Baltimore of robbery with a deadly weapon and sentenced to an indeterminate period not exceeding five years in the Maryland State Reformatory for Males. He was transferred to the House of Correction on July 14, 1954, paroled on September 19, 1955, and returned from parole on January 28, 1957. He filed a petition for a writ of habeas corpus in the Circuit Court for Charles County, which Judge Digges denied. He applied to the Court of Appeals for leave to appeal. Bell contended he should be released because: (i) he was apprehended in Alexandria, Virginia, on December 19, 1956, and was 'kidnapped' by Maryland authorities; (ii) he contested the matter at a hearing in Virginia and the court dismissed the charges against him; (iii) he was 'kidnapped' from the hallway of the Court House in Alexandria and returned to the House of Correction;
Questions presented
  • Whether the petitioner should be released from the House of Correction on a writ of habeas corpus because he was 'kidnapped' by authorities of the State of Maryland and brought into the State by unlawful means.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Horney, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. Because Digges, J., of the Circuit Court for Charles County, denied his petition for a writ of habeas corpus, William R. Bell has applied to this Court for leave to appeal. The petitioner was convicted in the Criminal Court of Baltimore (Warnken, J.) of robbery with a deadly weapon, and was sentenced to an indeterminate period of time not exceeding five years in the Maryland State Reformatory for Males. On July 14, 1954, he was transferred to the House of Correction, and was paroled on September 19, 1955.

He was returned from parole on January 28, 1957. He now contends that he should be released from the House of Correction on a writ of habeas corpus. He assigns as reasons why he should be granted the writ the following: (i) that he was apprehended in Alexandria, Virginia, on December 19, 1956, and was “kidnapped” by authorities of the State of Maryland; (ii) that he contested the matter at a hearing before the court in Virginia and the court dismissed the charges against him; (iii) that he was “kidnapped” from the hallway of the Court House in Alexandria and returned to the House of Correction; and (iv) that he was brought into the State of Maryland by unlawful means. Even if it is assumed that the petitioner’s return to this State from the Commonwealth of Virginia was the result of an illegal act on the part of State authorities, such acts cannot 616 form the basis for the issuance of the writ he seeks.

Since he is now in this State, no matter how he happens to be here, he is subject to its laws, and having been lawfully convicted, he cannot complain of the manner by which he was returned here to serve the remainder of his sentence. See Frisbie v. Collins (1952), 342 U. S. 519 , 96 L. Ed. 541 , reh. den. 343 U. S. 937 , 96 L. Ed. 1344 ; Rigor v. State (1905), 101 Md. 465 , 61 A. 631 , 4 Ann. Cas. 719; Davis v. Brady (1947), 188 Md. 113 , 51 A. 2d 827 ; McGuire v. State (1952), 200 Md. 601 , 92 A. 2d 582 ; and Jackson v. Olson (1946), 146 Neb. 885 , 22 N. W. 2d 124 , 165 A. L. R. 932, et seq. Application denied, with costs.