Maryland case law › Blakney v. Director of Patuxent Institution

Blakney v. Director of Patuxent Institution

239 Md. 704 (1965) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Denied✓ Good law
SummaryThis is the petitioner Blakney's second application for leave to appeal from a finding of defective delinquency. The prior history of his trouble with the law and incarceration is contained in Blakney v. Director, 230 Md. 610. The present finding of defective delinquency was made by Judge Manley, sitting without a jury, on November 23, 1964. Applicant made five charges of error in the trial below, which the Court of Appeals grouped into three contentions. First, contentions bearing solely on the weight of the evidence, which are not available as grounds for leave to appeal unless the trial judge was clearly in error, citing Johns v. Director, 239 Md. 411. Second, contentions attacking the sufficiency of the evidence, which the record showed to be without merit because Dr. Lerner, applicant's own psychiatrist, stated in his report that Blakney 'fits the description of a defective delinque
Questions presented
  • Whether contentions bearing solely on the weight of the evidence are available as grounds for leave to appeal.
  • Whether the evidence was sufficient to support the finding of defective delinquency.
  • Whether Dr. Boslow's testimony was inadmissible because individuals who prepared certain reports on which he in part based his expert testimony were not present in court and therefore not subject to cross-examination by the applicant or his counsel.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. This is the petitioner’s second application for leave to appeal. Blakney v. Director, 230 Md. 610 , contains the prior history of applicant’s trouble with the law and present incarceration. The present finding of defective delinquency was made by Judge Manley, sitting without a jury, on November 23,1964.

Applicant makes five charges of error in the trial below. In essence they amount to contentions (1) that bear solely on the weight of the evidence and are not available as grounds for leave to appeal, unless the trial judge was clearly in error see Johns v. Director, 239 Md. 411 ; (2) that attack the sufficiency of the evidence and are shown by the record to be without merit (Dr. Lerner, applicant’s own psychiatrist, in his report states that Blakney “* * * fits the description of a defective delinquent * * * quite well”); and (3) that challenge the admissibility of Dr. Boslow’s testimony because individuals who prepared certain reports on which in part he based his expert testimony were not “* * * present in court and therefore not subject to cross examination by the applicant or his counsel.” We have held repeatedly that Dr. Boslow’s testimony is not inadmissible because it relies in part on the reports of other trained persons. See, for example, Gilliard v. Director, 237 Md. 661 ; and Brunson v. Director, 239 Md. 128 , which points out that the applicant has the right to summon any of the persons whose names appear on such reports. Application denied.