Maryland case law › Board of County Commissioners for Carroll County v. John W. Pfaff Builders, Inc.
Board of County Commissioners for Carroll County v. John W. Pfaff Builders, Inc.
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Dismissed✓ Good law
SummaryIn these three consolidated cases, the Court of Appeals of Maryland granted certiorari on its own initiative to consider the validity of a Carroll County ordinance that imposed a one-year moratorium on the processing of residential development plans. By the time the Court was able to hear the case, the moratorium had expired and was not renewed. The Court determined that the issue it took the cases to decide was therefore moot. The Court further found no indication that the issue was likely to recur in any kind of similar factual setting, because the basis for the moratorium had itself been dealt with by subsequent county legislation. Consequently, the Court dismissed the appeals. The per curiam opinion does not reach the merits of the ordinance's validity, nor does it address any other legal questions. The disposition was that the appeals are dismissed, with costs to be paid by Carroll
Questions presented
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →- Whether the Carroll County ordinance imposing a one-year moratorium on the processing of residential development plans is valid.
23 PER CURIAM. We granted certiorari on our own initiative in these three cases and consolidated them for argument to consider the validity of a Carroll County ordinance that imposed a one-year moratorium on the processing of residential development plans. By the time we were able to hear the case, however, the moratorium had expired and was not renewed. The issue we took the cases to decide is therefore moot, and there is no indication that it is likely to recur in any kind of similar factual setting, as the basis for the moratorium has, itself, been dealt with by subsequent county legislation.
We shall therefore dismiss these appeals. APPEALS DISMISSED. COSTS TO BE PAID BY CARROLL COUNTY.