Maryland case law › Board of County Commissioners v. Pindell
Board of County Commissioners v. Pindell
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: AffirmedBurke, J.✓ Good law
SummaryAntoinette Pindell sued the County Commissioners of Howard County for personal injuries sustained while driving along a public highway in Howard County, caused by the dangerous condition of the road. A jury returned a verdict in her favor for $600, and the trial court entered judgment accordingly. The County Commissioners appealed. On appeal, the Court of Appeals noted that the case made by the parties, as relied on in this appeal, was the same as in a former appeal reported at 119 Md. 69, and that the evidence adduced to sustain their contentions was substantially the same. The Court therefore affirmed the judgment of the lower court. The opinion was delivered by Burke, J. The Court's reasoning rests on the principle that where a prior appeal in the same case established the governing law and the evidence on the subsequent trial is substantially the same, the prior decision controls and
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →Suit was brought against the County Commissioners of Howard County by Antoinette Pindell for injuries received by her while driving along and. over one of the public highways of said county, occasioned by the dangerous condition of the road, etc. The plaintiff obtained judgment in her favor on a verdict of $600. The defendants took this appeal. The Court held that the case made by the parties, as relied on in the appeal, was the same as in the former appeal, reported in 119 Md. 69 , and that the evidence adduced to sustain their contentions was substantially the same; and the judgment of the lower Court was affirmed. Burke, J., delivered the opinion of the Court.