Maryland case law › Brown v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

Brown v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

221 Md. 582 (2001) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Denied✓ Good law
SummaryBrown was convicted by a jury in 1947 of assault with intent to rape and sentenced to twenty years, later commuted to eighteen years. He filed a post-conviction application under the Maryland Post Conviction Procedure Act, alleging various trial errors, perjured testimony, and insufficiency of the evidence. The principal relief sought was a belated appeal, grounded on his alleged indigency in 1947. The court held that none of the alleged errors warranted relief under the Act. As to the perjured testimony claim, the court noted there was no allegation that the State knowingly used such testimony, citing State v. D'Onofrio. On the belated appeal request, the court found no showing that Brown made any effort to appeal within the allowed time—no order of appeal, no transcript request, or other action. Under Smith v. Warden, Person v. Warden, and Davis v. Warden, a defendant is not deprived o
Questions presented
  • Whether the applicant is entitled to post-conviction relief based on alleged errors or irregularities at his trial, allegedly perjured testimony, and insufficiency of the evidence.
  • Whether the applicant is entitled to a belated appeal on the ground of his alleged indigency in 1947, where no effort was made to appeal within the time allowed.
  • Whether the allegation of incompetence of counsel appointed to represent the applicant at his Post Conviction Procedure Act hearing has support in the record.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

PER Curiam. The applicant, Brown, was found guilty by a jury on a charge of assault with intent to rape in 1947 and was sentenced to twenty years imprisonment, subsequently commuted to eighteen years. By his application under the Post Conviction Procedure Act he complains of various alleged errors or irregularities and of allegedly perjured testimony at 584 his trial and of the insufficiency of the evidence to support his conviction. None of these is sufficient to support his application under the Act.

As to the alleged perjured testimony, there is no allegation that the State knowingly used such testimony. See State v. D’Onofrio, 221 Md. 20 , 155 A. 2d 643 . The principal relief sought by this application is a belated appeal on which the applicant’s complaints with regard to his trial could be urged. The ground upon which an appeal is sought at this time is the applicant’s alleged indigency in 1947.

The docket entries show that no appeal was taken, and there is no showing or suggestion that the applicant made any effort to appeal within the time allowed for an appeal either by filing an order of appeal, by seeking a transcript of the proceedings or otherwise. Under such circumstances, it has been held by this Court that a defendant has not been deprived by the State of his constitutional rights under the doctrine of Griffin v. Illinois, 351 U. S. 12 , even though his failure to seek an appeal may have been due to indigency. Smith v. Warden, 214 Md. 666 , 136 A. 2d 381 , cert. den. 356 U. S. 963 ; Person v. Warden, 217 Md. 650 , 141 A. 2d 743 , cert. den. 358 U. S. 853 ; Davis v. Warden, 217 Md. 662 , 143 A. 2d 77 . Therefore, although the learned trial judge dismissed the application for a different reason, the dismissal was correct.

The allegation of incompetence of counsel appointed to represent the applicant at his Post Conviction Procedure Act hearing seems to us without support in the record. Application denied.