Maryland case law › Browning v. Pasquay

Browning v. Pasquay

35 Md. 294 (1872) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedGrason, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThe appellant obtained an attachment under the Act of 1864, ch. 306, which was laid in the hands of John M. Frazier. After Frazier died, his executors moved to quash the attachment on several grounds. The Court of Appeals did not reach those grounds because it found the proceedings fatally defective in another respect: a fatal variance between the cause of action described in the short note and the cause of action set out in the attachment proceedings. The attachment described a promissory note dated June 1, 1864, for $5,000 payable June 1, 1869, with legal interest payable semi-annually. The short note described the cause of action as a promissory note dated June 1, 1867, payable June 1, 1869, with interest semi-annually from date. The Court held that the short note is a substitute for, and performs the office of, a declaration, and like a declaration it must substantially set forth the
Questions presented
  • Whether the short note in an attachment proceeding must substantially set forth the cause of action against the defendant, and whether a defect in this respect that would be fatal on demurrer is fatal to the short note on motion.
  • Whether a variance between the cause of action described in the short note and the cause of action exhibited in the attachment proceedings is fatal to the attachment.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Grason, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. The appellant obtained an attachment under the Act of 1864, chap. 306, which was laid in the hands of John M. 295 Frazier, and lie having afterwards died, his executors filed a motion to quash, and assigned several reasons therefor, which it is not necessary to pass upon, as the proceedings are fatally defective in another respect. The cause of action set out in the attachment is in the nature of a promissory note, bearing date the first day of June, 1864, for the payment of five thousand dollars on the first day of June, 1869, with legal interest payable semi-annually. The short note describes the cause of action as a promissory note bearing date June 1st, 1867, payable on the first of June, 1869, with interest semiannually from date.

In the case of Pearce vs. Boarman, Garnishee of Kendig and Brillinger, decided at October Term, 1870, and not reported, it was held by this Court that the short note is a substitute for, and performs the office of a declaration, and, like a declaration, it must substantially set forth the cause of action against the defendant, and any defect in this respect that would be fatal on demurrer will be fatal to the short note on motion. In Dean vs. Oppenheimer, 25 Md., 368 , it was also held that an attachment would be quashed for a defect in the short note. The cause of action described in the short note is not the same as that exhibited in the attachment proceedings, the first being dated the first of June, 1867, and the latter the first of June, 1864. The variance is fatal in a suit at common law. 1 Chitty on Plead., 304, 306, 307; 1 Greenl.

Ev., secs. 66, 67, 68; Gragg vs. Frye, 32 Maine, 283. And as the variance appears on the face of the proceedings in this case, the attachment cannot be sustained, and the judgment of the Court below will be affirmed. (Decided 13th March, 1872.) Judgment affirmed.