Maryland case law › Bush v. State

Bush v. State

223 Md. 382 (1960) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThe appellant, along with two co-defendants who did not appeal, was convicted of armed robbery by the Circuit Court for Prince George's County sitting without a jury. On appeal, the appellant contended that the evidence was insufficient to sustain the conviction because he was not properly identified. The identification challenge rested on the fact that the appellant was identified in open court by the witnesses as he sat with the co-defendants, who had been called by their names, advised to stand, and then to be seated. The Court of Appeals rejected this contention. The Court held that in a non-jury case involving the sufficiency of the evidence, its only function is to determine whether the evidence, or proper inferences therefrom, was sufficient for the trial court to find a verdict of guilty. The Court found the evidence clearly sufficient: the eyewitness victims positively identifie
Questions presented
  • Whether the evidence was sufficient to sustain the conviction where the appellant was identified in open court by the witnesses as he sat with the co-defendants, who had been called by their names, advised to stand, and then to be seated.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. The appellant (along with two other defendants who did not appeal) was convicted of armed robbery by the court sitting without a jury. The claim is that the evidence was insufficient to sustain the conviction because the appellant was not properly identified. The contention as to identity was based on the fact that the appellant was identified in open court by the witnesses as he sat with the co-defendants, who had been called by their names, advised to stand, and then to be seated.

The operator of a grocery store and his wife were held up at the point of a gun by the appellant while one of the other two stood watch and the third one rifled the cash register. At the trial, the eyewitness victims positively identified the appellant and another of the robbers. As the trio left the store in a run, they were pursued by the police and the appellant was caught. In a statement to the police, the appellant admitted that the subsequently recovered gun used in the holdup was his.

The officer also identified the appellant. On an appeal in a non-jury case involving the sufficiency of the evidence, the only function of this Court is to determine whether the evidence, or proper inferences therefrom, was sufficient for the trial court to find a verdict of guilty. Since the evidence was clearly sufficient to justify conviction, we must affirm. Hazel v. State, 221 Md. 464 , 157 A. 2d 922 (1960).

The credibility of the witnesses who identified the appellant and the sufficiency of the identification were matters for the trial court to determine. Brown v. State, 222 Md. 312, 160 A. 2d 95 (1960).