Maryland case law › Campion v. Director of Patuxent Institution

Campion v. Director of Patuxent Institution

237 Md. 640 (1965) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Denied✓ Good law
SummaryThis is a per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals of Maryland denying an application for leave to appeal from a redetermination that the applicant was still a defective delinquent. The applicant raised four contentions, all of which the court characterized as relating to the sufficiency and weight of the evidence: (a) the verdict was against the evidence; (b) there was no legally sufficient evidence for a finding that applicant was a defective delinquent; (c) the only testimony produced by the State was that of Dr. Boslow, and applicant's psychiatrist refuted this testimony; and (d) the verdict of the court was against the weight of the evidence. The hearing was held by a judge sitting without a jury. The court stated that a reading of the record shows there clearly was legally sufficient evidence to have taken the case to the jury had there been one, and that with reference to the we
Questions presented
  • Whether the verdict was against the evidence.
  • Whether there was no evidence legally sufficient for a finding by the court that applicant was a defective delinquent.
  • Whether the only testimony produced by the State was that of Dr. Boslow, and that applicant's psychiatrist refuted this testimony.
  • Whether the verdict of the court was against the weight of the evidence.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

PER Curiam. Upon this application for leave to appeal from a redetermina 641 tion that applicant was still a defective delinquent, the applicant contends that: (a) the verdict was against the evidence; (b) there was no evidence legally sufficient for a finding by the court that applicant was a defective delinquent; (c) that the only testimony produced by the State was that of Dr. Boslow, and that applicant’s psychiatrist refuted this testimony; and (d) the verdict of the court was against the weight of the evidence. It will be noted that all of the contentions relate to the sufficiency and weight of the evidence. The hearing was held by a judge, sitting without a jury.

A reading of the record shows that there clearly was legally sufficient evidence to have taken the case to the jury had there been one; and, with reference to the weight afforded the evidence by the court, his finding is amply supported by the evidence. Cf. Creswell v. Director, 234 Md. 620 . Application denied.