Maryland case law › Capritz v. State

Capritz v. State

1 Md. 569 (1852) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: ReversedLe Grand, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case came before the Court of Appeals on a writ of error from the Allegany County Court. The plaintiff in error, James Capritz, was indicted for violating the act of 1847, ch. 193, which prohibited the sale of spirituous liquors on Sunday. The indictment charged that Capritz, being a regular licensed ordinary keeper, 'unlawfully exposed for sale, and then and there did sell spirituous liquors, to wit, brandy,' but did not name the person to whom the liquor was sold. The Court, speaking through Chief Judge Le Grand, held that while time is immaterial in such an indictment—meaning the particular Sunday need not be precisely alleged or proved—it is essential that the name of the purchaser be stated. The Court reasoned that without the name of the purchaser, the defendant has no means of preparing his defense. The Court noted that if the name is unknown to the jurors, the purchaser may
Questions presented
  • Whether an indictment for selling spirituous liquors on Sunday under the act of 1847, ch. 193, must name the person to whom the liquor was sold, or may omit the name if unknown to the jurors.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

The opinion of the court was delivered by Le Grand, C. J. This case comes before us on a writ of error. The plaintiff in error was indicted in Allegany county court for a violation of the act of 1847, ch. 193. 574 The indictment-does not mention the name of the person to whom the liquor was sold, but merely avers, that “he, the said James Capritz, then and there being a regular licensed ordinary keeper, unlawfully exposed for sale, and then and there did sell spirituous liquors, to wit t brandy,” &c. In such an indictment, time is immaterial, that is to say, the particular Sunday is immaterial, If the offence’ be laid on a Sunday previous to the finding of the indictment, it will be sufficient, and the State will not be called upon to prove the day, in exact conformity with the designation of the indictment. It is essential, however, that the name' of the person to whom the liquor was sold should be mentioned.

State vs. Nutwell, 1 Gill, 54 . Unless this be furnished, the party has no means of preparing for his defence. Where the name of the purchaser is unknown to the jurors, he may be described as “a certain person to the' jurors aforesaid unknown.” Judgment reversed.