Maryland case law › Carroll v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

Carroll v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

201 Md. 647 (2001) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: DeniedMarkell✓ Good law
SummaryPetitioner, imprisoned under a 20-year sentence for assault with intent to rape committed at or near a prison camp near Elkton where he was a member, sought leave to appeal from denial of a writ of habeas corpus. He alleged he was not guilty and that the evidence so indicated, and that his court-appointed counsel 'denied' him 'taking the stand,' but he did not allege that he made any complaint to the court concerning this advice or denial. It appeared he had made repeated applications for habeas corpus on the same grounds, all denied. The Court of Appeals, in a brief per curiam-style opinion by Chief Judge Markell, held that habeas corpus cannot be made to serve the purpose of an appeal or a new trial of the question of guilt or innocence. The Court did not address the merits of the guilt or innocence claim or the ineffective assistance claim, because habeas corpus is not a substitute fo
Questions presented
  • Whether habeas corpus can be used to challenge the sufficiency of the evidence and to obtain a new trial on the question of guilt or innocence.
  • Whether a claim that court-appointed counsel 'denied' petitioner the right to testify can be raised in a habeas corpus proceeding where petitioner did not complain to the trial court.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Markell, C. J., delivered the opinion of the Court. This is an application for leave to appeal from denial of a writ of habeas corpus. Petitioner is imprisoned under sentence for 20 years on conviction of assault with intent to rape. The alleged offense was committed at or near a prison camp near Elkton of which petitioner was a member.

At the time he was under a 648 sentence of 4 years which has since expired. He alleges that he was not guilty and (with great detail) that the evidence so indicates. He alleges that he was “denied” “taking the stand” by his court-appointed counsel, but not that he made any complaint to the court concerning this advice or “denial”. It appears that he has made repeated applications for habeas corpus on the same grounds, all of which applications have been denied.

Habeas corpus cannot be made to serve the purpose of an appeal or a new trial of the question of guilt or innocence. Application denied, with costs.