Maryland case law › Coulehan v. White

Coulehan v. White

95 Md. 703 (1902) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThis was an election contest involving the counting of ballots in several classes. The lower court had rejected ballots in class 4, and the appellant challenged that ruling along with other rulings. The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam opinion, affirmed the lower court's rulings and order except for the treatment of class 4 ballots. The Court held that the class 4 ballots were erroneously rejected and should have been counted because they were not illegally marked within the rule laid down in Duvall v. Miller, 94 Md. 697. However, because counting those ballots instead of rejecting them made no change in the result, but only increased the majority of the candidate declared elected by the lower court, the judgment was affirmed without a new trial. The Court did not provide detailed facts or reasoning beyond this, and the opinion is brief. The legal questions presented include whether the
Questions presented
  • Whether the ballots included in class four were erroneously rejected and should have been counted because they were not illegally marked within the rule laid down in Duvall v. Miller, 94 Md. 697.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

PER CURIAM. With the exception of the rulings in relation to class 4 the rulings and order appealed from will be affirmed for the reasons given in the opinion of the Court below. In our opinion the ballots included in class four were erroneously rejected and'should have been counted, because they were not illegally marked within the rule laid down in Duvall v. Miller, 94 Md. 697 . Inasmuch as the counting of the ballots in class 4, instead of rejecting them makes no change in the result, but only adds to the majority of the candidate declared elected by the Court below, the judgment will be affirmed without a new trial.

Jtidgment affirmed.