Maryland case law › Crise v. Slagle

Crise v. Slagle

129 Md. 453 (1916) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DismissedPattison✓ Good law
SummaryThis appeal arose from a second bill filed by the mortgagors (Crise and wife) seeking to restrain a mortgagee and trustee from selling mortgaged property under a prior foreclosure decree. The prior decree (Slagle v. Crise, ante, p. 443) had authorized sale because of the mortgagors' alleged default in insuring the property for the mortgagee's benefit. The appellants continued to advertise the sale, and on July 5, 1916—the day of sale—the appellants filed their second bill and presented it to Judge Duu'ey at 11:30 A.M., seeking an injunction. The judge endorsed the application: 'application for injunction refused because presented to me at 11:30 A. M. on day of sale.' The appeal was taken from that refusal. The Court of Appeals (Pattison, J.) declined to pass on the merits of the injunction refusal because the record in No. 40 disclosed that the property had already been sold under the de
Questions presented
  • Whether the court erred in refusing to grant an injunction restraining the sale of the mortgaged property because of the alleged default of the mortgagors to insure the property for the benefit of the mortgagee.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Pattison, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. After the passage of the decree by Judge Bond in the case of Slagle v. Crise, ante, p. 443, the appellants in that case continued their advertisement of the sale of the property therein described, under- the decree in that case, because of the alleged default of Orise to insure and keep insured such property for 454 the benefit of the mortgagee, as covenanted in the mortgage. Whereupon the appellants here filed their second bill asking that the mortgagee and trustee named in the decree be restrained from selling said property thereunder, because of such alleged default. The bill was filed on the 5th day of July, 1916, and at 11:30 o’clock A. M. of that day, the day upon which the property was to be sold, it was presented to Judge Duu'ey, who was at that time sitting in Circuit Court No. 2, for his consideration.

As disclosed by the record the learned Judge endorsed thereon “application for injunction refused because presented, to me at 11:30 A. M. on day of sale.” It is from this action of the Court that this appeal is taken. The record in No. 40 also discloses that there has been a sale of the property under said decree. It would therefore be futile for us to pass upon the action of the Court in refusing the injunction, for even should we determine that he was in error in so doing, no injunction should now issue after the sale has been made. In the argument of the case before us it was said that the appellants here had filed exceptions to the ratification of said sale, but if not, the same may now be filed, and under such exception the question presented by the bill may be fully determined.

The appeal will therefore be dismissed. Appeal dismissed> each party to pay one-half of the costs, both in this Court and in the Court below.