Maryland case law › Dennison v. Wantz

Dennison v. Wantz

61 Md. 143 (1883) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: Aff'd in partIrving, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case involves two appeals arising from a single equity proceeding. The complainant filed a bill for relief (not for discovery) against the defendant. The defendant demurred to the bill, and the court overruled the demurrer. The defendant then appealed that order. After overruling the demurrer, the court passed an order requiring the defendant to answer by a certain day. The defendant also appealed that order. On the first appeal, the Court of Appeals affirmed the order overruling the demurrer, relying on the reasons assigned in the companion case of Dennison v. Yost, argued together with this case, which covered the same issues. On the second appeal, the Court dismissed the appeal because the order requiring the defendant to answer by a particular day is not a final order, or final in its nature, and therefore is not appealable under section 20 of Article 5 of the Code. The Court re
Questions presented
  • Whether the order overruling the demurrer to the complainant's bill should be affirmed.
  • Whether the appeal from the order requiring the defendant to answer by a particular day must be dismissed because that order is not appealable under section 20 of Article 5 of the Code.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Irving, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. There are two appeals in this record. 1. From an order overruling the demurrer to the complainant’s bill. 2. From an order passed after overruling the demurrer, requiring the defendant to answer by a certain day. 1.

The bill charges facts similar to those set out in Dennison vs. Yost, [ante p. 139,] which was argued with this case. The reasons assigned in that case, for affirming the order overruling the demurrer, cover this case also, and the order overruling the demurrer will be affirmed. 2. The appeal from the order requiring the defendant to answer by a particular day must be dismissed. That 144 order is not a final order, or final in its nature, and is not, therefore, appealable under section 20, of Article 5, of the Code.

The bill was filed for relief, and not for discovery only. Technically it was not for discovery at all; and the learned Judge says in his opinion, he did not so regard it. He regarded the call for answer, in the bill, as a merely formal demand on, a notification of, the defendant to defend the writ. The order, that the defendant answer by a certain day, was only a mode of giving leave to answer by a particular time, so that issue might be made; or if he failed to answer, the complainant might be entitled to proceed with his proof.

The defendant might have answered such facts as he could without danger of criminating himself, and might have pleaded his privilege, and omitted to answer the rest; and the question of the sufficiency of the answer would arise on exceptions to it, if any were taken. It is clearly not such an order, that an appeal will lie from it. (Decided 21st December, 1883.) Order overruling demurrer affirmed. Appeal from order requiring answer dismissed.