Maryland case law › Dockery's Lessee v. Maynard

Dockery's Lessee v. Maynard

1 Md. 209 (1756) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThis was an ejectment action for a tract of land in Queen Anne's County called Dangerfield. At trial, the plaintiff proved title to the land described in his declaration but offered no proof as to the boundaries or location of the tract. The defendant insisted that the plaintiff must prove the bounds and location of Dangerfield as located on the plot, and that the defendant should be permitted to offer evidence to disprove those bounds. The plaintiff countered that because the defendant had not taken any defense for lands lying within the bounds of Dangerfield as located by the plaintiff, the bounds were not in issue on the plot, and therefore the plaintiff need not prove the bounds, nor should the defendant be allowed to prove the bounds of any land laid down by him merely for illustration, as that was outside the issue. The Court agreed with the plaintiff and ruled accordingly, refusin
Questions presented
  • Whether, in ejectment, where the defendant has not taken defense for any lands lying within the bounds of the tract as located by the plaintiff, the plaintiff must prove the bounds and location of the land, and whether the defendant may offer evidence to disprove those bounds.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

EJECTMENT for a tract of land, lying in Queen Anne’s County, called Dangerjield. At the the trial of this cause at the Assises, the plaintiff proved his title to the land mentioned in his declaration, but made no proof as to the boundaries of the land. The defendant insisted, that the plaintiff should proceed to prove the bounds and location of Dangerjield, as located upon the plot, and that he should be admitted to offer evidence to disprove them; but the plaintiff insisted, that as no defence was taken for any lands, that lay within the bounds of the land called Dangerjield, as located by the plaintiff; that the bounds of the land was not in issue upon the plot, and that the plaintiff need not go into proof of the bounds of the land, and also, that the defendant should not go into the proof of the bounds of any land laid down by him for illustration, the same being out of the issue in this cause. Of this opinion was the Court, and ruled accord» ingly.

To which the defendant excepted. The Provincial Court overruled the exception, and gave judgment for the plaintiff