Maryland case law › Duke v. Director of Patuxent Institution

Duke v. Director of Patuxent Institution

232 Md. 651 (1963) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DeniedPer Curiam✓ Good law
SummaryThe applicant, confined at Patuxent Institution since his 1956 burglary conviction, sought leave to appeal from Judge Byrnes' January 25, 1963 determination, made without a jury in the Criminal Court of Baltimore, that he continued to be a defective delinquent under Sec. 5 of Art. 31 B of the Code (1962 Cum. Supp.). The applicant had been found a defective delinquent on May 14, 1957, and in November 1960 had withdrawn a petition for redetermination. The present redetermination proceedings were filed October 11, 1962; counsel was appointed and, pursuant to statute, the applicant was examined at State expense by a psychiatrist of his own selection, who reported on November 12, 1962. The sole basis of the application was that Judge Byrnes' determination was against the weight of the evidence. The record showed the applicant had made substantial progress toward rehabilitation, but revealed a
Questions presented
  • Whether Judge Byrnes' determination that the applicant continued to be a defective delinquent was against the weight of the evidence.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

652 Per Curiam. The applicant seeks leave to appeal from the determination of Judge Byrnes, sitting without a jury, in the Criminal Court of Baltimore, made on January 25, 1963, that the applicant continued to be a defective delinquent within the meaning of Sec. 5 of Art. 31 B of the Code (1962 Cum. Supp.). The applicant has a considerable criminal record.

He was convicted of burglary in May, 1956, was sentenced to the Penitentiary, was sent to Patuxent Institution and has been there since then. On May 14, 1957, he was found to be a defective delinquent. In November, 1960, he withdrew a petition for redetermination of his defective delinquency. The present proceedings were filed on October 11, 1962, counsel was appointed for him, and, pursuant to the statute, he was examined at State expense by a psychiatrist of his own selection, who submitted a report of his examination under date of November 12, 1962.

The basis of the present application, which is supported by a brief of counsel submitted on his behalf, is that Judge Byrnes’ determination is alleged to be against the weight of the evidence. An examination of the record shows that the applicant has made substantial progress towards rehabilitation, but that there is a difference of opinion between the psychiatrist selected by him and the psychiatrist who is the Superintendent of the Patuxent Institution and other members of the Patuxent staff, including a psychiatrist who had very recently examined him, as to whether the applicant had so far recovered as to have ceased to be a defective delinquent. The Superintendent’s prognosis was “reasonably hopeful with continued supervision and treatment.” The applicant has been subject to considerable “impulsivity,” which led him to disappear from an outside work detail and go to Texas in October, 1961. He turned himself in to the authorities and was sent back to Patuxent.

He had previously escaped in May, 1960, and had gone to California where he happened to be picked up in a dragnet in which police were searching cars for the perpetration of an offense in which the applicant was in no way involved. After an extensive hearing Judge Byrnes concluded that the 653 applicant was not yet ready for release and that he continued to be a defective delinquent. We find no sufficient basis in the record to warrant our holding that Judge Byrnes’ determination, which was primarily one of fact, was erroneous. See Maryland Rule 886 a.

Accordingly leave to appeal is denied. Application denied.