Maryland case law › Edwards v. State

Edwards v. State

16 Md. App. 255 (1972) · Court of Special Appeals of Maryland
Court of Special Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DismissedGilbert, J.✓ Good law
SummaryJames Martin Edwards and Thomas Glenn Conner appealed from the denial by Judge Ralph W. Powers of the Circuit Court for Prince George's County of their 'Motion To Quash Pending Charges.' The only question presented to Judge Powers was the alleged failure of the State to comply with the Interstate Detainer Act, Md. Ann. Code, art. 27, §§ 616A-R. The Court of Special Appeals, in an opinion by Judge Gilbert, held that the appeal must be dismissed because the order denying the motion was interlocutory and the appeal was prematurely taken under Rule 1087. The court distinguished between an attack based on the statutory right to be tried within a specified time under the Interstate Detainer Act and an attack based on the constitutional right to a speedy trial under the Sixth Amendment and Article 21 of the Maryland Declaration of Rights. The court noted that an order denying a motion grounded
Questions presented
  • Whether the denial of a motion to quash pending charges based on an alleged failure of the State to comply with the Interstate Detainer Act, Md. Ann. Code, art. 27, §§ 616A-R, is immediately appealable.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Gilbert, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. James Martin Edwards and Thomas Glenn Conner, appellants, appeal from the denial by Judge Ralph W. Powers of their “Motion To Quash Pending Charges”, in the Circuit Court for Prince George’s County. We shall dismiss the appeal on the ground that it is an 256 interlocutory order and the appeal has been prematurely taken. Rule 1087.

We glean from the record that the only question presented to Judge Powers on the “Motion To Quash” was the alleged failure of the State to comply with the provisions of the Interstate Detainer Act, codified as Md. Ann. Code, art. 27, §§ 616A-R. Appellants’ attack was, therefore, made upon the statutory right to be tried within a specified time as distinguished from the constitutional right to a speedy trial. Sixth Amendment, Constitution of the United States; Art. 21, Maryland Declaration of Rights. Of course, an order denying a motion grounded ón the constitutional right to a speedy trial is immediately appealable. Raimondi v. State, 8 Md. App. 468 , 261 A. 2d 40 (1970) ; King v. State, 5 Md. App. 652 , 249 A. 2d 468 (1969).

An appeal from a denial of the statutory right to be tried within the specified time under Art. 27, § 616A-R must await final judgment. Rule 1087; Md. Ann. Code Art. 5, § 1. Appeal dismissed.