Maryland case law › Ellinger v. Crowl

Ellinger v. Crowl

17 Md. 361 (1861) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedGoldsborough, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case came before the Court of Appeals on a re-hearing concerning the validity of a deed from Henry Crowl to his wife, Agnes Crowl, challenged by creditors. The Court adopted the Chief Justice's statement of the pleadings, evidence, and applicable law, but disagreed with his assessment of the testimony's effect. The majority held that the circumstances established both a valuable and good consideration for the deed, and that at the time of the conveyance, the grantor retained other property sufficient to satisfy all his debts shown in the record. Consequently, the deed could not be successfully assailed by creditors. The Court affirmed the decrees of the circuit court with costs. Chief Judge LeGrand dissented. The decision turned on the sufficiency of consideration and the grantor's solvency at the time of the transfer, which precluded a finding of fraudulent conveyance as to credito
Questions presented
  • Whether the circumstances establish a valuable and good consideration for the deed from Henry Crowl to his wife, Agnes.
  • Whether the grantor had property other than that mentioned in the deed sufficient to pay all his indebtedness shown by the record, such that the deed cannot be assailed by creditors.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Goldsborotjgh, J., delivered the opinion of this court, on .the re-hearing. We adopt as correct the statement of the pleadings and evidence as made by the Chief Justice, and also his statement of the law as applicable to the case, but dissent from his view of the effect of the testimóny. We are of opinion that the circumstances detailed in the proceedings, establish a valuable as well as a good consideration for the deed from Henry Crowl to his wife, Agnes, and also that at the time of 379 Vhe making of the said deed, the grantor had property other than that mentioned in the deed, sufficient to pay all his indebtedness shown by this record. This being so, the deed cannot be successfully assailed by his creditors, and we therefore affirm the decrees of the circuit court.

(Decided Oct. 29th, 1861.) Deorees affirmed, with costs. LeGranp, C. J., dissented.