Maryland case law › Fisher v. Warden

Fisher v. Warden

225 Md. 642 (1961) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Denied✓ Good law
SummaryIn this per curiam opinion, the Maryland Court of Appeals denied an application for leave to appeal from an order denying post conviction relief. The applicant, convicted of larceny and sentenced to three years, raised four contentions: (i) that he was innocent; (ii) that his court-appointed counsel directed him not to testify; (iii) that he was convicted on perjured testimony of the complaining witness; and (iv) in the alternative, that he should receive a lesser sentence or probation. The Court held that the claim of innocence, involving the sufficiency of the evidence, is not cognizable under the Post Conviction Procedure Act because the statute expressly provides that the remedy is not a substitute for remedies incident to trial (such as a motion for a new trial) or a direct appeal. As to the claim that counsel prevented him from testifying, the Court held that such an allegation, wi
Questions presented
  • Whether the applicant's claim of innocence, involving the sufficiency of the evidence, is cognizable in a post conviction proceeding.
  • Whether the applicant's contention that his court-appointed counsel prevented him from testifying entitles him to post conviction relief.
  • Whether the applicant's claim that he was convicted on perjured testimony entitles him to post conviction relief.
  • Whether the applicant is entitled to a reduction of sentence or probation.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. In this application for leave to appeal from the order denying post conviction relief from his imprisonment for larceny, the applicant contends (i) that he is innocent; (ii) that he did not testify in his own behalf because his court-appointed counsel directed him not to do so; (iii) that he was convicted on the perjured testimony of the complaining witness; and (iv) in the alternative, the applicant seeks the grant of a lesser sentence or probation. As to the claim of innocence, involving as it does the sufficiency of the evidence, the statute specifically provides that the post conviction remedy is not a substitute for remedies incident to trial (such as a motion for a new trial) or a direct appeal. Code (1960 Cum.

Supp.), Art. 27, § 645A (b); Barbee v. Warden, 220 Md. 647 , 151 A. 2d 167 (1959). With respect to the contention that his counsel prevented him from testifying, we have often held that such an allegation, without more, is without merit. See Rayne v. Warden, 223 Md. 688 , 165 A. 2d 474 (1960). Likewise, the claim of perjury, absent a showing that the State knowingly used perjured testimony, is also without merit.

State v. D’Onofrio, 221 Md. 20 , 155 A. 2d 643 (1959). Finally, the request for a reduction of sentence or probation was a matter which should have been seasonably ad 644 dressed to the trial court. In any event, the sentence of three years was within the statutory limits. See Rahe, Jr. v. State, 222 Md. 508 , 161 A. 2d 696 (1960).

Application denied.