Maryland case law › Foster v. Director of Patuxent Institution

Foster v. Director of Patuxent Institution

235 Md. 671 (1964) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DeniedPer Curiam✓ Good law
SummaryIn this per curiam opinion, the Court of Appeals of Maryland denied an application for leave to appeal from a determination of defective delinquency made by Judge Byrnes. The applicant, through counsel, raised several contentions: (1) the evidence was insufficient to support the determination; (2) Dr. Boslow was improperly permitted to express an opinion based in part on reports of other experts; (3) incompetency of counsel, collusion, and other indefinite claims; (4) denial of a private hearing; and (5) that his one-year sentence for assault had expired before the determination, causing the proceeding to abate. The Court found no merit in the sufficiency and expert-opinion contentions, citing Tippett v. Director and McDonough v. Director. It dismissed the allegations of incompetency of counsel, collusion, and other indefinite claims as too indefinite to require discussion, citing Porter
Questions presented
  • Whether the evidence was sufficient to support the determination of defective delinquency.
  • Whether Dr. Boslow was improperly permitted to express an opinion based in part upon the reports of other experts.
  • Whether the applicant's allegations of incompetency of counsel, collusion, and other claims warranted relief.
  • Whether the applicant was entitled to a private hearing.
  • Whether the applicant's one-year sentence for assault expired before the determination, causing the proceeding to abate.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. In this application for leave to appeal from a determination of defective delinquency by Judge Byrnes, the chief contentions made by counsel for the applicant go to the sufficiency of the evidence, and the fact that Dr. Boslow was permitted to express an opinion based in part upon the reports of other experts. There is no merit in these contentions. See Tippett v. Director, 233 Md. 647, 648 , and McDonough v. Director, 229 Md. 626, 672 634 .

The applicant makes additional allegations as to incompetency of counsel, collusion, and other claims too indefinite to require discussion. Porter v. Director, 232 Md. 639 . He claims that he sought and was denied a private hearing. There is no requirement in the Maryland statute for private hearings.

The applicant claims that his one year sentence for assault expired before the determination, and that the proceeding abated. The record shows that although he was acquitted of perverted practice upon a minor and convicted on the assault charge, he was convicted of enticing and harboring the same minor and sentenced to two years, to run consecutively. Since there is no factual basis for the claim of abatement we need not discuss it further. Application denied.