Maryland case law › Glen Morris-Glyndon Supply Co. v. McColgan

Glen Morris-Glyndon Supply Co. v. McColgan

100 Md. 479 (1905) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: AffirmedSchmucker, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis appeal was heard together with the appeal of George R. Carr and wife upon one record, and presented no difference except that the Carr appeal was taken by the mortgagor while this one was taken by one of his judgment creditors. The order appealed from finally ratified a sale of mortgaged property made under a power of sale contained in the mortgage. The mortgage was executed in February, 1902, and the appellant's judgment was not rendered until long after that date; indeed, the debt for which the judgment was obtained was not contracted until after the making of the mortgage. The Court held that the lien of a judgment attaches only to such interest in the debtor's land as he has at the time of its rendition or thereafter acquires, and that a judgment is only a general lien which must be subordinated to the superior equity of a prior specific lien even though created by a defective m
Questions presented
  • Whether the exceptions of the appellant judgment creditor to the ratification of a sale of mortgaged property made under a power of sale contained in the mortgage were properly overruled, where the appellant's judgment was rendered and its debt contracted after the making of the mortgage.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Schmucker, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. The appeal in this case was taken from the order of the Cir 480 cuit Court for Carroll County which we confirmed on the appeal of George R. Carr and wife at the present term of Court. The two appeals were heard together upon one record and there is no difference between them except that the former appeal was taken by the mortgagor and this one was taken by one of-his judgment creditors. The order appealed from finally ratified a sale of mortgaged property made under a power of sale contained in the mortgage.

(Decided March 21st, 1905.) It appears from the face of .the record that the mortgage was executed in February, 1902, and the present appellant’s judgment was not rendered until long after that date. In fact it appears that the debt for which the judgment was obtained was not contracted until after the making of the mortgage. The lien of a judgment attaches only to such interest in the debtor’s land as he has at the time of its rendition or thereafter acquires. We have repeatedly held that a judgment is only a general lien and must be subordinated to the superior equity of a prior specific lien even though created by a defective mortgage or conveyance.

Dyson v. Simmons, 48 Md. 215 ; Valentine v. Seiss, 79 Md. 187 ; Skinner v. Houghton, 92 Md. 86 ; Hartsock, v. Russell, 52 Md. 625 ; Knell v. Green Street Bldg. Assn., 34 Md. 67 . • The exceptions of the present appellant were therefore properly overruled for the reasons set forth in our opinion in Carr’s appeals, except in so far as those reasons applied to the estoppel worked against Carr by his- own conduct. The lien on the land acquired by the appellee as purchaser at the sale made under the mortgage must under the cases which we have cited be held to be superior to that of this appellant and the ordér of the ratification of the sale to the appellee must also be affirmed upon the present appeal. Order affirmed with costs.