Maryland case law › Goebel v. Mayor and City Council of Baltimore

Goebel v. Mayor and City Council of Baltimore

93 Md. 749 (1901) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Aff'd in partMcSherry, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case involved a challenge to the assessment and taxation of certain properties located on the south side of the Baltimore and Frederick Turnpike Road, between Eighth Street and Hurley's Lane, as city property rather than rural land. The appellant, Goebel, owned two of twenty-four houses in that area. The same contention was made as in Sindall's case: that these houses were not within a block formed by opened and constructed avenues, streets, or alleys, and therefore should not be taxed as city property. The Court of Appeals held that the property was no longer rural 'landed' property but built-up city property, and thus liable to be assessed and taxed as similar property within the original city limits from and after the year 1900. However, the Court also held that the collection of taxes for the year 1900 must be restrained. The decree below dismissed the bill and denied all relief
Questions presented
  • Whether the houses owned by the appellant, located between Eighth Street and Hurley's Lane and fronting on the turnpike road, were within a block formed by opened and constructed avenues, streets, or alleys, and thus subject to assessment and taxation as city property.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

The Court said: Whilst, the property described in these 750 proceedings is somewhat differently located from that mentioned in Sindall’s case, ante p. 526, precisely the same principles applied there must control here. Fronting on the south side of the Baltimore and Frederick Turnpike road and between what is called Eighth street on the west and Hurley’s lane on the east, there are twenty-four houses standing. Two of these are owned by the appellant. The same contention is made here as was made in Sindall's case, viz., that these houses were not within a block formed by opened and constructed avenues, streets, or alleys ; and the same decision must be reached.

The property between Eighth street and Hurley’s lane and fronting on the turnpike road is no longer rural “landed” property, but is built up city property; and from and after the year nineteen hundred is liable to be assessed and taxed as similar property situated within the original city limits is assessed and taxed. But the collection of taxes for the year nineteen hundred must be restrained. As the decree appealed against dismissed the bill and denied all the relief claimed, though the plaintiff was entitled to a part, the decree must be reversed in part and affirmed in part; and the cause will be remanded. filed June 12th, 1901. Bernard Carter, for the appellant.

Wm: Pinkney Whyte and Olin Bryan, for the appellees. Opinion by McSherry, C. J., Fowler, Briscoe and Jones, JJ., dissent.