Maryland case law › Gohn v. Director of Patuxent Institution

Gohn v. Director of Patuxent Institution

236 Md. 342 (1964) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: OtherHenderson, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryGohn filed an application for leave to appeal from the denial of post conviction relief by Judge Sodaro. He raised two contentions: (1) that no witness testified against him at his original trial regarding the commission of the crime, and (2) that he was serving two sentences for the same crime. The Court, in a per curiam opinion by Chief Judge Henderson, found no support for the first contention in the record. The circumstantial evidence—Gohn found injured near a stolen crashed automobile, his admission of riding in it—was sufficient to support the conviction for unauthorized use. As to the second contention, the Court noted that Gohn was convicted and sentenced to three years, but the sentence was later stricken to allow a belated new trial motion. After the motion was denied, a new three-year sentence was imposed without credit for the ten months already served, effectively increasing
Questions presented
  • no witness testified against me at my original trial with respect to the commission of the crime
  • he is serving two sentences for the same crime
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Henderson, C. J., delivered the opinion of the Court. In this application for leave to appeal from a denial of post conviction relief by Judge Sodaro, the applicant first contends that “no witness testified against me at my original trial with respect to the commission of the crime.” If we assume, without deciding, that this allegation goes not merely to the sufficiency of the evidence (as Judge Sodaro thought) but to a denial of a constitutional right, we find no support for the allegation in the record. Judge Sodaro stated in his opinion filed herein that he had reviewed the transcript of the testimony at the trial for the purpose of passing upon the legality of his arrest (a point abandoned in this application). He pointed out that the applicant was found in an injured condition, near a stolen automobile that had crashed on the Jones Falls Expressway.

He was taken to the Maryland General Hospital, and freely admitted that he had been riding in the damaged car, although he denied that he was the driver. The circumstantial evidence plus his admission was clearly sufficient to permit the trier of facts to draw the inference that he was guilty of unauthorized use, the crime for which he was convicted. The second contention is that he is “serving two sentences for the same crime.” It is based on the fact that the applicant 344 was convicted by Judge Harris on May 20, 1963, and sentenced on June 26, 1963, to not more than three years in the Maryland Institution for Men, the sentence to run from March 19, 1963, the date he was committed to jail. But on September 11, 1963, the sentence was stricken out by Judge Harris, to permit the applicant to proceed with a motion for new trial.

The basis for this ruling was that the applicant had signed a letter asking for new trial the day following his conviction, but it had been sent to the Court of Appeals. Judge Harris ruled that the applicant was entitled to a belated hearing on the motion, and struck out the sentence. After the motion was heard and denied, he imposed a three-year sentence, without any credit for the time spent in prison, some ten months additional to the original sentence. While it can hardly be maintained that applicant is “serving two sentences,” it might well be contended that the increase in the second sentence was beyond the authority of the sentencing court under the circumstances.

We are constrained to grant leave to appeal in order that this point may be briefed and argued, and shall appoint counsel for the applicant for this purpose. Leave to appeal granted.