Maryland case law › Gorsuch v. Thomas

Gorsuch v. Thomas

57 Md. 334 (1882) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedAlvey✓ Good law
SummaryThis was a bill in equity filed by the appellant (Gorsuch) seeking an injunction to restrain execution on a judgment at law recovered against him. The judgment had been entered by confession in January 1815, extended in March 1815 for $195.39 with interest, and credits of $81.20 (December 1816) and $50 (December 1819) were entered. A fieri facias issued for the balance in 1880. The appellant alleged that he had paid the amount of an account filed at the extension before suit, that the judgment creditor agreed to give credit for that amount but failed to do so, and that the two credits entered were for less than actually paid, leaving little or nothing due. The bill did not state the amount of credits claimed or when payments were made. The court below sustained a demurrer and dismissed the bill. On appeal, the Court of Appeals affirmed. The Court held that equity will not relieve a party
Questions presented
  • Whether the right to have execution restrained upon the allegations of the bill is sufficient to warrant equitable relief by injunction.
  • Whether a party who has a good defense at law and neglects to avail himself of it, or suffers judgment by neglect, can have relief in a court of equity.
  • Whether the discovery of evidence since the recovery at law forms sufficient ground for an application to a court of equity for relief.
  • Whether the appellant is entitled to have additional credits entered on the judgment, and if so, what is the proper remedy.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Alvey, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. The bill in this case was filed for an injunction to restrain execution on a judgment at law; and the question, of the right to have the execution restrained, upon the-allegations of the bill, is raised by a demurrer to the bill. The Court below sustained the demurrer, and dismissed the hill; and in so doing we find no error. There is really nothing alleged on the face of the bill that could afford ground of relief by injunction.

It is not alleged that the judgment at law was obtained by fraud, or by such surprise or mistake of the defendant, that, by the use of due diligence and proper-attention to the case, he could not have avoided. According to the short entries of the judgment, a copy of which is filed with the bill, the judgment was entered by confession in January, 1815, on terms to be filed. In March following this judgment was extended for $195.39, with interest from that date; and, according to the entries, a note and account were then filed, though copies of them have not been exhibited with the bill. In December, 1816, a credit of' $81.20, and in December, 1819, another credit of $50,. were entered on the judgment; and a fi. fa. was then issued for the balance, returnable to the March Term of' Court, 1880.

The appellant in his bill alleges that he had paid the amount of the account filed at the extension of the judgment, before the suit was brought, and that the plaintiff in the judgment subsequently agreed that he should have credit for that amount on the judgment;. but that no such credit has been given. He also alleges that the two credits entered on the judgment are erroneous, as being for amounts less than were actually paid; and that there would be but a small amount, if anything at all, due on the judgment, if the proper credits were-given. He fails, however, to state the amount of the credits to which he is entitled, or when the payments, were made. 339 It is perfectly well settled, that if a party has a good defence at law, and neglects to avail himself of it there, in the proper way, and at the proper time, or if he suffers judgment to go against him by neglect, he can have no relief in a Court of equity. .Nor does the mere fact of the discovery of evidence since the recovery at law form sufficient ground for an application to a Court of equity lor relief: hut there must be conscience, good faith, and duo diligence shown, as a condition upon which such application will be entertained. Here, however, it is not pretended that the evidence, made the ground of the application in this case, could not have been produced and made available at law, by the use of proper care and diligence.

To entertain such an application as the present would he altogether without precedent. 6 Gill & J., 312; 20 Md., 305 . But if the party be really entitled to have additional credits entered on the judgment to those already given, the remedy is verjT ample, and, at the same time, summary, by which full relief may he obtained. By motion in the Court where the judgment was recovered, a rule may be obtained upon tbe plaintiff to show cause why such credits shall not he allowed; and upon such rule the Court may stay the execution until the matter of the right to the credits claimed be fully investigated; and if it be found that the judgment is subject, to credits not given, or that it has been satisfied, the Court may direct entries to be made accordingly. Formerly such relief was obtained by audita querela, hut in modern practice it is obtained in a more summary way by motion.

Job vs. Walker, 3 Md., 129 ; Shafer vs. Shafer, 6 Md., 518 ; Huston vs. Ditto, 20 Md., 320 , 321 ; U. S. vs. McLemore, 4 How., 286. With such remedy in the Court where the judgment was obtained, there can he no sort of propriety in coming to a Court of equity for relief. 340 (Decided 13th January, 1882.) We shall therefore affirm the decree appealed from, with costs to the appellees. Decree affirmed.