Maryland case law › Green v. Sprogle

Green v. Sprogle

16 Md. 579 (1861) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: ReversedLe Grand, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case, like its companion Green v. Caulk (ante, 556), was an action to recover the value of work and materials furnished by the plaintiff in repairing the defendant's house. At trial, the defendant reserved four exceptions. The Court of Appeals, applying the reasoning from Green v. Caulk, reversed the circuit court on the first three exceptions and affirmed on the fourth. The fourth exception concerned testimony of declarations made by a Mr. Randall. The court held that these declarations could not bind the plaintiff because they were not made to him nor in his presence. The judgment was reversed and a procedendo awarded.
Questions presented
  • Whether the circuit court erred in its rulings on the first three exceptions.
  • Whether the circuit court erred in admitting testimony of declarations made by Mr. Randall, where those declarations were not made to the plaintiff nor in his presence.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Le Grand, C. J., delivered the opinion of this court: This, like the case of Green vs. Caulk, (ante., 556,) is an action instituted to recover the value of certain work done and materials furnished, by the plaintiff, in the repair of the house of the defendant. At the trial below the defendant reserved four exceptions. For the reasons assigned in the opinion filed in the case referred to, we reverse the Circuit court on the first three exceptions. The court is affirmed on the fourth exception.

The testimony could not have the effect of binding the plaintiff, inasmuch as the declarations of Mr. Randall were not made to him, nor in his presence. Judgment reversed and procedendo awarded.