Maryland case law › Grove v. Swartz

Grove v. Swartz

45 Md. 227 (1876) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: ReversedBowie✓ Good law
SummaryThis case came before the Court of Appeals on a motion to dismiss the appeal and on the merits. The appellee moved to dismiss on the ground that one of the nominal appellants, George Grove, had died before the appeal was prayed. The Court overruled the motion, reasoning that the record entry 'prayer of defendants attorney, for an appeal' could be read in the possessive singular, referring only to the surviving defendant, William K. Grove, and that each defendant had an independent right of appeal. On the merits, the appellant raised for the first time in this Court that the referee had not returned the award under his hand and seal. The Court held that although it ordinarily reviews only questions raised and decided below, exceptions to an award are analogous to a motion in arrest of judgment and are not within the operation of the Act of 1825, ch. 117, so the objection was properly befo
Questions presented
  • Whether the appeal should be dismissed because one of the nominal appellants died before the prayer for an appeal was filed in the Court below.
  • Whether the referee's failure to return the award under his hand and seal, raised for the first time on appeal, is a valid objection.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Bowie, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. There is a motion to dismiss the appeal in this case, on the ground that one of the nominal appellants had died before the prayer for an appeal was filed in the Court below. The appellee has filed an affidavit, showing that George Grove, one of the defendants and nominal appellants, died on or about the 26th of January, 1876, four or five weeks before the appeal was taken, and no counter evidence is adduced by the appellant William K. Grove. Assuming the facts to he true as stated, it does not clearly appear from the record, that the appeal was taken or intended to he taken in the names of both defendants.

The entry on the record is as follows, viz., “1876 March 1st, prayer of defendants attorney, for an appeal to the Court of Appeals filed.” The word “defendants’’ in the above citation maybe taken in the possessive case singular number and applies only to one, meaning the surviving defendant. Each defendant, if living, had the right of appeal, hut one being dead, the term “defendants attorney” could only mean William K. Grove’s attorney. The motion to dismiss must therefore he overruled. Several objections were raised to the award below which were overruled, the award affirmed and judgment rendered thereon in favor of the plaintiff, from which action of the Court .the defendant appeals.

In this Court an objection is taken which was not made below, viz., that the referee has not returned the award under his hand and seal. Ordinarily, this Court only reviews questions which it appears from the record were raised and decided below, but exceptions to an award, are analogous to a motion in arrest of judgment, and are 229 not within the operation of the Act of 1825, ch. 117. Price & Martin vs. Thomas & George, 4 Md., 520. 521. (Decided 21st June, 1876.) This objection was taken and held to he good in the case above cited.

This Court referring to the award, said Ci We discover several defects apparent upon the face of the proceedings of the arbitrators in this case, any one of which is fatal to the award. The only one to which we need refer, is the omission of the arbitrators to return their award under seal. The submission or reference requires, that the award should be returned under hand and seal of the arbitrators, and the omission to do so is fatal, and renders the whole proceedings void.” 4 Md., 521 . In the present case, the rule of reference required the award to be returned under the hand and seal of the referee.

It professes to he so, hut there is no seal affixed. The judgment below must he reversed and cause remanded for further proceedings. Judgment reversed, and cause remanded.