Maryland case law › Groverman v. Spencer
Groverman v. Spencer
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedMason, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case came before the Court of Appeals of Maryland and resulted in a division of the four judges, two favoring affirmance and two favoring reversal. Although individual opinions were prepared by the judges, the whole court determined not to file them because they would decide nothing that could govern any future case and would likely lead to misapprehension. The court announced a prospective practice: in all future cases where the court is equally divided, no opinions will be filed. The decree was therefore affirmed by a divided court, with costs in both courts. The opinion, delivered by Mason, J., does not address the merits of the underlying dispute, nor does it state any facts, legal questions, or reasoning beyond the practice regarding divided courts. It is a per curiam-style statement of practice and disposition.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →Mason, J., delivered the following opinion of this court, in reference to its practice in such cases in future: In this case the court are divided. Two of the judges are of opinion the decree ought to be affirmed, and the two other judges are of opinion that it ought to be reversed. Although opinions representing the views of the different judges have been prepared, the whole court think it proper not to file them, for they determine nothing which would gov 215 ern any future ease, and therefore would iti all probability lead to misapprehension hereafter. In future, in ali cases of a divided court, a similar practice will be pursued.
Decree affirmed, by a divided court, with costs in both courts.