Maryland case law › Hendleman v. State

Hendleman v. State

159 Md. 579 (1930) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThe appellant, Maurice Hendleman, was tried before a jury on a charge of larceny. During closing argument, the assistant state's attorney read the indictment, including the defendant's name and two aliases: "Maurice Hendleman, alias Worcester Reds, alias Bob Wilson." Defense counsel excepted on the ground that no evidence had been adduced to connect the aliases to the accused. The trial court responded that the prosecutor was merely describing the indictment and reminded the jury that they were to decide only what was shown by the evidence. On appeal, the Court of Appeals of Maryland (per curiam) affirmed the judgment. The Court reasoned that a jury would inevitably become aware of the names on the indictment when they took it to the jury room to deliberate, and would probably learn of them otherwise during the proceedings. Given the trial court's warning that the jury should consider on
Questions presented
  • Whether the trial court erred in permitting the assistant state's attorney, during argument to the jury, to read the additional names (aliases) from the indictment when no evidence had been adduced to show their application to the accused.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

580 The opinion was delivered per Curiam. During the argument before the jury on a trial of the appellant on a charge of larceny, the assistant state's attorney, in the words of an exception taken, “referred to the indictment in this case, reading the name of the defendant as Maurice Hendleman, alias Worcester Reds, alias Bob Wilson.” The exception was taken to the reading of the additional names on the ground that no evidence of their application to the accused had been adduced. To this the court replied that the assistant state’s attorney was describing the indictment, and the jurymen had been told, and knew, that they were not to decide anything not in evidence in the case. It is sufficient to point out that, as a jury would inevitably be made aware of the names on an indictment when they took it to the jury room to consider their verdict, and would probably become aware of them otherwise during the proceeding before them, and, in view of the warning remark of the court that the jury were to consider only what had been shown by evidence before them, no injury to the accused could be attributed to the mere reading of the additional names during the argument.

Judgment affirmed, with costs to the appellee.