Maryland case law › Hirons v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

Hirons v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

196 Md. 679 (2001) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DeniedCollins, J.✓ Good law
SummaryPatrick John Hirons applied for leave to appeal from the refusal of a writ of habeas corpus, his fourth such application. He alleged that he was not furnished with copies of his robbery indictments even though his court-appointed attorney requested them from the State's Attorney. The Court of Appeals held that even if true, this fact would not entitle him to release on habeas corpus, citing Fisher v. Swenson and State ex rel. Ballam v. Warden. The Court also noted that the papers showed Hirons was sentenced by Judge France on May 4, 1949, to five years for assault with intent to murder and one year for carrying a dangerous weapon, consecutive, and by Judge Tucker on October 6, 1949, to twenty years in each of three robbery cases, concurrent, all running from March 15, 1949. Because the sentences imposed by Judge France had not expired, the application was premature. The Court relied on S
Questions presented
  • Whether the failure to furnish copies of indictments to a defendant, even if true, entitles him to release on habeas corpus.
  • Whether the application for habeas corpus is premature because the sentences imposed by Judge France have not expired.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Collins, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. This is an application by Patrick John Hirons for leave to appeal from the refusal of a writ of habeas corpus. He has previously applied three times for the writ and has been refused. Petitioner alleges that he was not furnished with copies of his indictments charging him with robbery even though his attorney, appointed by the court, requested these from the State’s Attorney.

Even if this were true, such a fact would not entitle him to release on habeas corpus. Fisher v. Swenson, Md., 64 A. 2d 680 124, certiorari denied, 337 U. S. 933 , 69 S. Ct. 1489 , 93 L. Ed. 1740 ; State ex rel. Ballam v. Warden, 196 Md. 644 , 75 A. 2d 95 . The papers here show he was sentenced by Judge France on May 4, 1949, to five years from March 15, 1949 for assault with intent to murder and to one year for carrying a dangerous weapon, these sentences to run consecutively.

On October 6, 1949, he was sentenced by Judge Tucker for robbing with a deadly weapon in three cases to twenty years in each case, each sentence to run concurrently from March 15, 1949. No question is raised as to the sentences of Judge France and as these sentences have not expired this application is premature. State ex rel. Thomas v. Warden, 196 Md. 648 , 74 A. 2d 830 .

State ex rel. Czaplinski v. Warden, Md. Penitentiary, 196 Md. 654 , 75 A. 2d 766 . Application denied, with costs.