Maryland case law › Hopkins v. Warden of Maryland House of Correction

Hopkins v. Warden of Maryland House of Correction

213 Md. 634 (1974) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DeniedCorrins, J.✓ Good law
SummaryPetitioner Hopkins sought leave to appeal from the denial of a writ of habeas corpus. He had been convicted by the trial magistrate of Worcester County on two charges—larceny of a watch and unauthorized use of an automobile—and sentenced to concurrent terms totaling twenty-two months in the Maryland House of Correction. He did not contest the larceny conviction but challenged the unauthorized-use conviction on three grounds: (1) that the trial magistrate refused to allow him to appeal and told him he would have to appeal from the House of Correction; (2) that he was held incommunicado and then tried without warning at 8 P.M. on April 30, 1956, before his witnesses and lawyer could appear the next morning; and (3) that the evidence was insufficient to convict him. The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam opinion by Judge Corrins, held that none of these contentions could be raised on habeas
Questions presented
  • Whether the contention that petitioner was wrongfully prevented from taking or perfecting an appeal can be raised on habeas corpus.
  • Whether the complaint that petitioner was tried without notice and without counsel or witnesses can be raised on habeas corpus.
  • Whether sufficiency of the evidence to convict can be raised on habeas corpus.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Corrins, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. This is an application for leave to appeal from the denial of .a writ of habeas corpus. Petitioner alleges that he was arrested on April 28, 1956, and charged with larceny of a watch and unauthorized use of an automobile. He was tried by the trial magistrate of Worcester County and found guilty and was sentenced to eleven months in each case in the Maryland House of Correction, the sentences to run concurrently, a total of twenty-two months on the two charges.

Petitioner makes no complaint as to his conviction for larceny and his petition here is based on the conviction for unauthorized use. He states that he told the trial magistrate that he wanted to appeal the verdict and asked to be released on bail pending hearing on appeal in the Circuit Court. He further states that the magistrate replied that he could not appeal at that time, he would have to appeal from the House of Correction. In Paff v. Warden, 200 Md. 660 , 90 A. 2d 173 , the petitioner, who was convicted of petty larceny by the trial magistrate at Frederick, Maryland, alleged that “he requested appeal and was refused”, and that at the Frederick jail he requested use of the telephone to call the magistrate “for an appeal” and also wrote a letter to the magistrate, but the jailer refused him permission to telephone and tore the letter to bits.

Judge Markell said in that case: “This contention cannot be raised on habeas corpus. If petitioner 636 was wrongfully prevented from taking or perfecting an appeal, application should be made to the Circuit Court for Frederick County for hearing of his appeal and decision whether he was wrongfully prevented from taking it. Bernard v. Warden, 187 Md. 273, 282 , 49 A. 2d 737 ; Coates v. State, 180 Md. 502 , 25 A. 2d 676 .” Petitioner further contends that after being arrested on April 28, 1956, he was held in jail and not allowed to use the telephone to send messages to anyone. However, on April 30th he was informed that he would be given a hearing on May 1, 1956, at 9 A. M. He was then allowed to telephone his intended wife, who visited him at the jail.

He arranged with her to have witnesses and a lawyer to be at the hearing, which was to be the following morning. Without warning he was taken before the trial magistrate for trial at 8 P. M. on April 30th. At the hearing he had no one there. When the people interested in. the case appeared the next morning at 9 A. M. they were told that the case was over and that he had already left for the House of Correction.

This complaint should be raised on appeal and not on habeas corpus. Petitioner further contends that there was not sufficient evidence to convict him on the charge of unauthorized use. Sufficiency of the evidence cannot be raised on habeas corpus. Walker v. Warden, 210 Md. 654 , 123 A. 2d 447 .

Application denied, with costs.