Maryland case law › Howell v. State

Howell v. State

278 Md. 389 (1976) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: ReversedMurphy, C. J. (dissenting)⚠ Negative treatment (1)
SummaryThis case concerns whether a tear gas pistol qualifies as a "handgun" under Maryland's statutory definition, which requires a weapon capable of discharging a missile propelled by gunpowder or a similar explosive. The majority of the Court of Appeals held that a tear gas pistol is not a "handgun" because tear gas is not a "missile" within the natural and ordinary meaning of the term, and because the propellant, while explosive, is not gunpowder or a similar explosive as contemplated by the statute. The dissent, authored by Chief Judge Murphy, disagreed, arguing that the expert testimony established that the tear gas was composed of fine solid particles (projectiles) propelled by a violent explosive, and thus the weapon fit the statutory definition. The dissent would have affirmed the Court of Special Appeals, which had held that the tear gas gun was a handgun. The majority's reasoning res
Questions presented
  • Whether a tear gas pistol is a "handgun" within the meaning of Maryland Code, Article 27, §§ 36B-36F.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Murphy, C. J. dissenting: The Court holds that a tear gas pistol is not a “handgun” within the meaning of the statute because it is not a “firearm” capable of emitting a missile propelled by gunpowder “or a similar explosive.” I respectfully dissent. At trial a gun expert testified that the “tear gas” was propelled by an extremely violent explosive and was itself actually a large quantity of very fine particles and not a gas at all. He referred to the particles as projectiles. Relying on this testimony, the Court of Special Appeals held that “the propellant was an explosive charge” and that “what it propelled were projectiles or missiles.” Howell and Kaschenbach v. State, 29 Md. App. 646, 654 , 350 A. 2d 145, 397 150 (1976).

The court added that “the size of the projectile is of no moment,” and concluded: “[A] weapon, in the form of a pistol which will, or which is designed to, or which may readily be converted to expel, by an explosive force, tear gas in the form of finely divided solids or particles, is a ‘handgun’ within the meaning of art. 27, § § 36B-36F.” 29 Md. App. at 655 , 350 A. 2d at 151 . The majority of this Court, however, has limited the requisite propellant to gunpowder or a similar explosive and has determined that tear gas “is not a missile within the natural and ordinary signification of the term.” 278 Md. at 396, 364 A. 2d at 801.1 cannot agree and therefore conclude, as did the Court of Special Appeals, that a tear gas gun fits within the statutory definition of a “handgun.” The majority lists seven definitions of “firearm” and from them concludes that gunpowder “or a similar explosive” must be the propellant if a weapon is to be considered a firearm and, consequently, a handgun. Admittedly, the propellant for a tear gas gun is not gunpowder, but it is undisputed that it is a violent explosive. The majority offers no explanation for its refusal to treat the tear gas charge as an explosive within the contemplation of the statute, and I see no legislative intent to exclude it.

The Court also finds that tear gas is not a missile, as that term is ordinarily understood. As heretofore indicated, the expert at trial testified that tear gas is not gaseous but composed of many fine particles, and his testimony was undisputed. I agree with the Court of Special Appeals that these particles are projectiles or missiles and that “Whether it be as big as an artillery shell or as small as a subatomic particle, it is still a projectile.” §9 Md. App. at 654, 350 A. 2d at 150 . In my opinion, then, a tear gas gun does fit within the statutory definition of handgun, for it is a weapon which discharges a projectile, propelled by an explosive.