Maryland case law › In the Matter of Reinstatement of Cooke

In the Matter of Reinstatement of Cooke

423 Md. 475 (2011) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Other✓ Good law
SummaryIra C. Cooke, who had been disbarred by consent, petitioned for reinstatement to the Bar of Maryland. After oral argument, the Court of Appeals took a final vote on the petition. Judge Murphy did not participate because he had retired and was not eligible for recall at the time of the final vote. The remaining six participating judges divided evenly, 3-3, so the petition failed to obtain the concurrence of a majority of the judges sitting. Under Section 14 of the Maryland Constitution, an equal division of the judges sitting has the effect of affirming the decision appealed from, and the concurrence of a majority of those sitting is sufficient for a decision. The Court construed the constitutional phrase 'affirming the decision appealed from' to refer, in this reinstatement context, to Cooke's earlier disbarment by consent. Because the petition did not garner a majority of the sitting ju
Questions presented
  • Whether a petition for reinstatement to the Bar of Maryland must be denied when the participating judges of the Court of Appeals are equally divided, so that the petition fails to obtain the concurrence of a majority of those sitting, under Section 14 of the Maryland Constitution.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

ORDER Upon consideration of the papers filed in this matter, oral argument having been heard, and a final vote having been taken on the petition for reinstatement by the Court (Judge Murphy not participating in the final vote because he retired and was not eligible for recall at the time of the final vote), which resulted in a tie (3-3), it is this 28th day of November 2011, ORDERED, that the petition of Ira C. Cooke for reinstatement to the Bar of Maryland be, and the same is, hereby denied, by operation of Section 14 of the Maryland Constitution which provides, in pertinent part that: 476 Five of the judges shall constitute a quorum, and five judges shall sit in each case unless the Court shall direct that an additional judge or judges sit for any case. The concurrence of a majority of those sitting shall be sufficient for the decision of any cause, and an equal division of those sitting in a case has the effect of affirming the decision appealed from if there is no application for reargument as hereinafter provided. In any case where there is an equal division or a three to two division of the Court a reargument before the full Court of seven judges shall be granted to the losing party upon application as a matter of right. For purposes of applying this section to the matter at hand, the language “affirming the decision appealed from” is construed to refer here to Mr. Cooke’s earlier disbarment (by consent).

Thus, the failure of his petition for reinstatement to garner a majority of the sitting judges who participated in the final vote on his petition results in the denial of his petition and maintenance of his disbarment, subject to the reargument provisions of Section 14.