Maryland case law › In the Matter of the Hon. Mary C. Reese

In the Matter of the Hon. Mary C. Reese

457 Md. 656 (2018) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Dismissed✓ Good law
SummaryThe Maryland Commission on Judicial Disabilities referred three consolidated cases (CJD 2015-132, -133, -134) to the Court of Appeals, alleging that Judge Mary C. Reese of the District Court of Maryland for Howard County violated Maryland Rules 18-101.1 and 18-102.5 by presiding over a peace order hearing in the District Court sitting in Carroll County. The Commission proceeded under Maryland Rule 18-407(j) and (k), and the Court of Appeals considered the matter on an expedited basis pursuant to Maryland Rule 18-408(a). The Court held oral argument on March 6, 2018. The Court concluded that the Commission did not prove by clear and convincing evidence that Judge Reese lacked the competence and diligence necessary to complete her judicial responsibilities or otherwise committed sanctionable conduct as defined by Maryland Rule 18-401(j). The Court therefore dismissed the proceeding against
Questions presented
  • Whether the Commission proved by clear and convincing evidence that Judge Reese lacked the competence and diligence necessary to complete her judicial responsibilities or otherwise committed sanctionable conduct, as defined by Maryland Rule 18-401(j), as a result of her presiding over a peace order hearing in the District Court of Maryland sitting in Carroll County.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

WHEREAS, the Maryland Commission on Judicial Disabilities ("Commission"), pursuant to Maryland Rule 18-407(j) and (k), referred to this Court the case of In the Matter of the Honorable Mary C. Reese, Judge of the District Court of Maryland for Howard County, Tenth Judicial Circuit , Case Nos. CJD 2015-132, CJD 2015-133, and CJD 2015-134 for expedited consideration pursuant to Maryland Rule 18-408(a), and WHEREAS, the Commission alleged that Judge Reese violated the Maryland Code of Judicial Conduct, specifically Maryland Rules 18-101.1 and 18-102.5, as a result of her presiding over a peace order hearing in the District Court of Maryland sitting in Carroll County, and WHEREAS, this Court having concluded that the Commission did not prove by clear and convincing evidence that Judge Reese lacked the competence and diligence necessary to complete her judicial responsibilities or otherwise committed sanctionable conduct, as defined by Maryland Rule 18-401(j), and WHEREAS, this Court held Oral Argument on March 6, 2018 and for reasons to be stated in an opinion later to filed, it is this 22 nd day of March 2018, ORDERED , by the Court of Appeals, that this proceeding against Judge Mary C. Reese be, and is, hereby dismissed with prejudice.