Maryland case law › Isaacs v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary
Isaacs v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DeniedPer Curiam✓ Good law
SummaryRobert Isaacs, convicted of murder, filed an application for leave to appeal to the Maryland Court of Appeals from the denial of post-conviction relief by the lower court. The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam opinion, denied the application on two independent grounds. First, the petitioner failed to comply with Maryland Rule BK46 b, which requires an applicant to state reasons why the lower court's order should be reversed or modified. The Court held that this procedural defect alone justified denial, citing Jones v. Warden and Taylor v. Warden. Second, despite the procedural default, because the petitioner was convicted of murder, the Court exercised its discretion to review the contentions he had presented to the trial judge. The Court found no merit in any of those contentions and adopted the reasons stated by Judge Byrnes in his opinion below. The application was therefore denied. T
Questions presented
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →- Whether the application for leave to appeal should be denied because the petitioner failed to state any reasons why the lower court's order should be reversed or modified, as required by Maryland Rule BK46 b.
- Whether the contentions presented to the trial judge have merit, given that the petitioner was convicted of murder.
PER Curiam. The petitioner, Robert Isaacs, fails to state in his application for leave to appeal to this Court any reasons why the lower court’s order should he reversed or modified, as required by Maryland Rule BK46 b, and his application may be denied for that reason alone. Jones v. Warden, 241 Md. 728 , 217 A. 2d 338 ; Taylor v. Warden, 238 Md. 645 , 210 A. 2d 514 . However, because the petitioner was convicted of the crime of murder, we have reviewed the contentions he put to the trial judge.
We find no merit in any of them and for the reasons stated by Judge Byrnes in his opinion the application will be denied. Application denied.