Maryland case law › James v. State ex rel. Shlasar
James v. State ex rel. Shlasar
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedMason, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis case arose from a suit on a constable's bond. The plaintiff declared generally upon the bond without assigning any breaches of its condition. The defendants demurred to the declaration, arguing that it was defective because it failed to set out the cause of action—i.e., it did not assign the breaches of the bond's condition. The county court overruled the demurrer. On appeal, the Court of Appeals (Mason, J.) affirmed, relying on the identical question decided in Scott v. State, use of Ducker, 2 Md. 284 (1852). The Court held that a declaration on a constable's bond need not assign breaches of the condition; the general declaration is sufficient. The judgment was affirmed.
Questions presented
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →- Whether a declaration on a constable's bond that does not assign breaches of the condition is defective for failure to set out the cause of action.
Mason, J., delivered the opinion of this court. In this case the plaintiff declared generally upon a constable’s bond, without assigning in his declaration any breaches of its condition. The defendants demurred to the declara 212 tion, and in argument contended, that it is defective, because it does not set out the cause of action — in other words, because it does not assign the breaches .of the condition of the bond of which he complains. This is the identical question raised and decided in the case of Scott vs. the State, use of Ducker, 2 Maryland Rep., 284 .
For the reasons assigned in that case, we think the county court were right in overruling the present demurrer. Judgment affirmed.