Maryland Court of Appeals (General Court)Disposition: Other✓ Good law
SummaryThis brief report concerns a criminal prosecution in which the defendant, Jenifer, sought appellate review. Counsel S. Chase argued that a writ of error was the proper mode of proceeding in criminal cases, including treason and felony, while an appeal was the proper mode in civil suits. Chase contended that the criminal or civil character of a proceeding depended on the nature of the offense, not the mode of proceeding, and warned that allowing an appeal in a criminal case would permit a sheriff or other officer to convert a criminal matter into a civil controversy by submitting to the proceeding. The reporter's note indicates that, at the request of the Court, counsel argued only whether an appeal would lie, without addressing whether a bill of exceptions was proper. The case was continued under a curia advisare vult until September term 1774, when it was struck off the docket. No final
Questions presented
Whether a writ of error or an appeal is the proper mode of proceeding in criminal cases.
S. Chase argued, that a writ of error was proper in criminal cases, and admitted that by the late resolutions a writ of error will lie in all cases as well of treason as felony ; but that an appeal was the proper mode of proceeding in civil suits, and that this was the meaning of the terms of the act of Assembly. That a criminal prosecution became so, not by reason of the mode of proceeding, but on account of the offence, and if this proceeding was allowed, a sheriff or other officer might always by submitting make his case of the nature of a civil controversy. The late Thomas fenings, Esq. in his note of this case,, says, that at the request of the Court, the counsel argued that no appeal would lie, without considering whether a bill of exceptions was proper. This case was continued under a Curia ad. milt till Sep-, iember term, 1774, when it was struck off the docket.