Maryland case law › John Hyde & Co. v. Bradford's

John Hyde & Co. v. Bradford's

1 Md. 82 (1730) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Affirmed✓ Good law
SummaryThis was an action of debt upon a bond. At trial, the plaintiff produced the bond without any probate indorsed thereon, i.e., without the oath required by the act of Assembly that no part of the bond had been paid or satisfied. The defendant objected to the bond's admission on that ground. The Court overruled the objection and held that the bond was good evidence without any oath or probate, because the plaintiffs were not in Maryland at the time of the bond's execution and had resided in England ever since, and the bond was executed in Maryland. The defendant excepted to this opinion. The jury returned a verdict for the plaintiff. At the succeeding term, the Provincial Court gave judgment upon the verdict, stating that the determination of bills of exceptions on trials at bar does not lie before them, being only determinable on appeals and writs of error, which had been the constant pra
Questions presented
  • Whether a bond executed in Maryland is admissible as evidence without the oath or probate required by the act of Assembly, where the plaintiffs were not in Maryland at the time of execution and have resided in England ever since.
  • Whether the Provincial Court may determine a bill of exceptions on a trial at bar.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

THIS was an action of debt upon a bond; the plaintiff at the trial produced the bond without any probate indorsed thereon, 44 that no part or parcel of the same bond had 44 been paid, or any thing else given or delivered towards 44 satisfaction thereof,” according to the act of Assemhly; (a) and upon that ground the defendant objected: But the Court overruled the objection and said that the bond was good evidence without any oath or probate, because the plaintiffs were not in Maryland at the time of the execution of the bond, and have resided in England ever since, and the said bond was executed in Maryland. To this opinion the defendant excepted. Verdict for the plaintiff. At the succeeding term the Provincial Court gave judgment upon the verdict, saying 44 that the deter-44 mination of bills of exceptions on trials at bar does not lie 44 before them, being only determinable on appeals and 44 writs of error, which hath been the constant, practice.” See the act of 1722, c. 10.