Maryland case law › Kelly v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

Kelly v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

243 Md. 717 (1966) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Denied✓ Good law
SummaryKelly filed a post conviction petition under the Maryland Post Conviction Procedure Act, Code Art. 27, §§ 645A-645J, challenging his 12 August 1964 conviction (for the second time) of robbery with a deadly weapon, for which he received a twenty-year sentence in the Maryland Penitentiary. No direct appeal was taken. He raised three contentions, all rejected by Judge Cullen below and all rejected by the Court of Appeals. First, Kelly claimed entitlement to the benefit of Schowgurow v. State, 240 Md. 121, 213 A.2d 475 (1965), which invalidated the Maryland jury selection system. The Court held that because Kelly's conviction became final well before Schowgurow was decided, he does not come within its ambit, citing Sturgis v. Warden, 241 Md. 728, 217 A.2d 341 (1966). Second, Kelly alleged that Judge Harris, who presided at his non-jury trial, was biased. Third, he alleged that his conviction
Questions presented
  • Whether applicant is entitled to the benefit of the decision in Schowgurow v. State, 240 Md. 121, 213 A.2d 475 (1965).
  • Whether applicant's allegations that Judge Harris was biased and that his conviction resulted from the use of the fruits of an illegal arrest may be raised in a post conviction proceeding where no direct appeal was taken.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. On 12 August 1964 applicant was convicted, for the second time, of robbery with a deadly weapon. He was sentenced to twenty years in the Maryland Penitentiary. No appeal was taken from that conviction.

The details of his first conviction will be found in Kelly v. Warden, Maryland Penitentiary, 230 F. Supp. 551 (D. Md. 1964); Kelly v. Warden, 229 Md. 642 , 184 A. 2d 622 (1962). On 26 October 1965, Kelly filed his present post conviction petition in which he raised three contentions, all of which were found to be without merit by Judge Cullen below. We also find them to be without merit. Applicant claims he is entitled to the benefit of our decision in Schowgurow v. State, 240 Md. 121 , 213 A. 2d 475 (1965). •His conviction having become final well before Schowgurow , he does not come within the ambit of that case.

Sturgis v. Warden, 241 Md. 728 , 217 A. 2d 341 (1966). In addition, applicant claims that Judge Harris (who presided at his non-jury trial) was biased and that his [Kelly’s] conviction resulted from the use of the fruits of an illegal arrest. The Post Conviction Procedure provided by Code, Art. 27, §§ 645A-645J (1957, Cum. Supp. 1965) is not a substitute for an appeal or a means of obtaining a belated appeal.

Montgomery v. Director of Patuxent Institution, 235 Md. 672 , 202 A. 2d 758 (1964). These allegations of error “could have been made on direct appeal” but Kelly took no appeal. There arises, therefore, a “rebuttable presumption that * * * [Kelly] intel 719 ligently and knowingly” waived such allegation. Code, Art. 27, § 645A (1957, Cum.

Supp. 1965). Applicant has made no showing that he was denied a right of appeal or any other facts which might rebut the presumption. Application denied.