Maryland case law › Kent v. Waters

Kent v. Waters

18 Md. 53 (1861) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: OtherTuck, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis matter comes before the Court on a motion for re-argument filed by the appellee's counsel during the term. The Court, consisting of Bowie, C.J., Bartol, Goldsborough, and Cochran, JJ., overruled the motion and announced that it would adhere to the rule adopted by the Supreme Court of the United States in Brown v. Aspden, 14 How. 25: that a re-argument of a case decided by this court will not be granted unless a member of the court who concurred in the judgment desires it, and when that is the case, it will be ordered without waiting for the application of counsel. The opinion also contains a dissent by Tuck, J., from so much of the above opinion as places a construction on the deed from Waters to Speed. The text provided does not include the majority's underlying opinion or reasoning on the deed construction; it only reports the denial of the motion for re-argument and the dissentin
Questions presented
  • Whether a re-argument of a case decided by this court should be granted upon the application of counsel.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Tuck, J. I dissent from so much of the above opinion as places a construction on the deed from Waters to Speed. A motion was made, during the term by the counsel for the appellee, for a re-argument of this case. At the hearing of this motion before Bowie, C. J., Bartol, Goldsborough and Cochran, J., the court overruled the same, and said that they would adhere to the rule adopted by the Supreme Court of the United States in the case of Brown vs. Aspden, 14 How., 25, viz: That a re-arguinent, of a case decided by this court, will not be granted unless a member of the court who concurred in the judgment desires it, and, when that is the case, it will be ordered without waiting for the application of counsel.