Maryland case law › Laird v. Director of Patuxent Institution

Laird v. Director of Patuxent Institution

237 Md. 178 (1964) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DeniedHenderson, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryLaird filed an application for post conviction relief, denied by Judge Harlan, attacking the jurisdiction of the court that committed him to Patuxent Institution as a defective delinquent. The jurisdictional point had not been raised in his earlier application for leave to appeal from the defective delinquency determination (Laird v. Director, 234 Md. 604), but the Court held it was properly before it, citing Simon v. Director, 235 Md. 626, 629, Blizzard v. State, 218 Md. 384, 388, and Doxzen v. Director, 236 Md. 657. The Court recounted Laird's sentence history: 3 years for automobile larceny in 1955; 7 years for robbery in 1956, consecutive from November 30, 1955; 6 months for escape in Anne Arundel County in 1959, consecutive; and 18 months for manslaughter in Baltimore City in 1961, consecutive. He was transferred to Patuxent for examination on November 7, 1962. The Court rejected hi
Questions presented
  • Whether the point attacking the jurisdiction of the court that committed him to Patuxent is properly before the Court on this application for post conviction relief.
  • Whether Anne Arundel County was the place of his last sentence.
  • Whether his sentences had expired at the date of his transferral to Patuxent on November 7, 1962.
  • Whether the Act is unconstitutional.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Henderson, C. J., delivered the opinion of the Court. In this application for post conviction relief, denied by Judge Harlan in the court below, the attack is upon the jurisdiction of the court that committed him to Patuxent, a point not raised 179 in his application for leave to appeal from the determination of defective delinquency denied in Laird v. Director, 234 Md. 604 . That the point is properly before us seems clear from Simon v. Director, 235 Md. 626, 629 , Blizzard v. State, 218 Md. 384, 388 , and Doxzen v. Director, 236 Md. 657 . He was sentenced to 3 years for automobile larceny in 1955, and 7 years for robbery in 1956, to run consecutively from November 30, 1955.

In 1959, he was convicted in Anne Arundel County of escape and sentenced to 6 months, to run consecutively with his prior sentences. While on parole in 1961, he was sentenced in Baltimore City to 18 months, consecutively to the other sentences, for manslaughter. He was transferred to Patuxent for examination on November 7, 1962. His claim that Anne Arundel County was the place of his last sentence is obviously unfounded, McCloskey v. Director, 230 Md. 635 , as is his claim that his sentences had expired.

His sentences run until November 30, 1967, and even with allowance for earned credits if applicable would not have expired until approximately November 30, 1963. See Code (1964 Supp.), Art. 27, sec. 700. They had not expired at the date of his transferral to Patuxent on November 7, 1962. There is no merit in his contention that the Act is unconstitutional.

See McDonald v. Director, 236 Md. 642 , and Eggleston v. State, 209 Md. 504 . Application denied.