Maryland case law › Lewis v. Levy

Lewis v. Levy

16 Md. 85 (1860) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: ReversedTuck, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThe appellants (Levy and others) levied an execution against a third party upon goods in a store. The complainant (Lewis) claimed title to those goods under the third party and filed a bill in equity seeking an injunction to restrain the sale of the goods under the execution. The Court of Appeals, in an opinion by Tuck, J., held that the injunction was improperly granted. The Court reasoned that the bill did not show that the property was of such a character, or possessed such peculiar value or interest to the owner, that he could not be adequately compensated by damages at law. The Court emphasized that if such an injunction could be maintained, it would be difficult to imagine a case where the execution of a judgment at law could not be prevented, frustrating plaintiffs in the recovery of just demands. The Court distinguished Bridges v. M'Kenna, 14 Md. 258, where relief was granted sol
Questions presented
  • Whether an injunction will lie to restrain the sale of goods under an execution where the complainant claims title to the goods and does not show that the property has a peculiar value or that damages at law would be inadequate.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Tuck, J., delivered the opinion of this court. The appellants have suggested one ground of error in the present record that we think conclusive of the case; we need not, therefore, express any opinion as to the other points so fully argued. There is nothing here which distinguishes the case from many others, in which it has been held that an injunction will not lie. The complainant, claiming goods in a store, on which the appellants levied an execution against a third party, under whom the complainant asserts title, seeks the restraining process of equity to prevent their being sold under that writ.

The bill does not show that the property was f such a character, or possessed such peculiar value, or interest 91 to the owner, that he could not be adequately compensated by damages at law. If this injunction can be maintained, we can scarcely imagine a case where the execution of a judgment at law could not be prevented, and plaintiffs altogether frustrated in the recovery of just demands, even when asserted in the most solemn form. (Decided June 7th, 1860.) In the case of Bridges, et al.,vs. M'Kenna, 14 Md. Rep., 258, relief was granted, but merely on the ground that the complainant, being a feme covert, could obtain redress in a court of equity. But for that reason the bill would have been dismissed.

We do not consider that there is any thing in the record showing that, the defendants below waived their right to pro. ceed against the property in question. Decree reversed, and bill dismissed with costs.