Maryland case law › Lloyd v. Tilghman

Lloyd v. Tilghman

1 Md. 85 (1736) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: Other✓ Good law
SummaryThis early Maryland land-title case arose from a dispute over priority between a prior survey and a subsequent grant. The court held that the constant usage of the country gives a prior survey a right against a prior grant made on a subsequent survey. The opinion also addressed the proper mode of pleading and proof: the express conditions of warrants not to run into other surveys should be set forth in a special verdict, and it is customary to return and record surveys as well as grants in the land-office so that all parties may have recourse to them. The court further held that the usage of the country must be found specially in the verdict. If an objection is made that the usage is the common law of the country and need not be found, the answer is that although it may be the common law, because the ultimate determination may occur elsewhere where the usage is not known, it is proper to
Questions presented
  • Whether a prior survey gives a right against a prior grant on a subsequent survey.
  • Whether the express conditions of warrants not to run into other surveys should be set forth in a special verdict.
  • Whether the usage of the country must be found specially in a special verdict, and whether it is proper to have it found even if it is the common law of the country.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

It has been the constant usage of the country, that a prior survey has always been deemed to give a right 89 against a prior grant on a subsequent survey. It is proper •fio set forth in the special verdict the express conditions of warrants not to run into other surveys. That it is customary to return to and. record surveys as well as grants in the land-office, to which all parties may have recourse. The usage of the country must be found specially, and if an objection should be made to its being so found, on pretence that it is the common law of the country, and need not be found; the answer is, that though it may be so, yet, as the determination may be ultimately elsewhere, where the usage is not known, it is proper to have it found; and there is no doubt but that a due regard will be had to it in the dernier resort.