Maryland case law › Love v. Love

Love v. Love

158 Md. 481 (1930) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: OtherParke, J. (dissenting)✓ Good law
SummaryThis opinion is a dissenting opinion by Parke, J., in Love v. Love, 158 Md. 481 (1930). The dissent addresses whether the evidence was legally sufficient to submit the issues of mental capacity and undue influence to the jury in a will caveat proceeding. The dissenting judge states that the only witness who expressed an opinion that the testatrix was incompetent at the time she made the will was the family doctor, and that his opinion was shown by his testimony in chief and cross-examination not to have been based upon any evidence of mental incapacity, and consequently was without probative force. The dissent concludes that the doctor's testimony was insufficient to carry the case to the jury, and that there was no legally sufficient evidence from which the jury could have found for the caveators on the issue of either mental capacity or undue influence. The dissent cites Donnelly v. Do
Questions presented
  • Whether there was legally sufficient evidence from which the jury could have found for the caveators on the issue of mental capacity.
  • Whether there was legally sufficient evidence from which the jury could have found for the caveators on the issue of undue influence.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Parke, J., filed the following dissenting opinion: It will serve no useful purpose for the writer of this dissent to make an analysis of the testimony on the record, so conclusions will be stated. The only witness who expressed an opinion that the testatrix was incompetent at the time she made the will was the family doctor, whose opinion was shown by Ms testimony in chief and by his cross-examination not- to have been based upon any evidence of mental incapacity and, consequently, without any probative force. His 486 testimony, therefore, was insufficient to carry the case to the • jury, and, in the judgment of the writer, there was no legally sufficient evidence from which the jury could have found for the caveators on the issue of either mental capacity or undue influence. Donnelly v. Donnelly, 156 Md. 81, 84, 85 ; Horner v. Buckingham, 103 Md. 450, 453, 454 ; Berry v. Safe Deposit Company, 96 Md. 60, 61 .