Maryland case law › Mahaney v. Lazier

Mahaney v. Lazier

16 Md. 69 (1860) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: ReversedLe Grand, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis is an appeal from an order of the Superior Court of Baltimore City granting an injunction to restrain proceedings at law to recover the amount of a bond. The Court of Appeals first addressed whether the answers filed by the appellants, though unverified by affidavit, were sufficient to authorize an appeal under section 21 of Article 5 of the Code, which allows an appeal 'the answer of the party appealing being first filed in the cause.' The Court held that the answers were a sufficient compliance with the Code to authorize the appeal, noting that under section 103 of Article 16, a defendant need not make oath to his answer unless required by the complainant, and the bill did not require sworn answers. However, the Court distinguished this from a motion to dissolve an injunction, for which the answer must be sworn to under the latter clause of section 103, whether the oath be require
Questions presented
  • Whether the answers of the appellants, though not verified by affidavit, are sufficient to authorize an appeal under section 21 of Article 5 of the Code.
  • Whether the charge of fraud in the bill is sufficient to show jurisdiction in equity.
  • Whether the claim of the complainants is stated with sufficient distinctness and supported by exhibits to show that they are creditors of the defendant Mahaney.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Le Grand, C. J., delivered the opinion of this court. This is an appeal from an order of the Superior court of Baltimore city, granting an injunction to restrain proceedings at law to recover the amount of a bond. By the 21st section of the 5th Article of the Code an appeal is allowed, “the answer of the party appealing being 73 first filed in the canse.” In this case the answers of the appellants are filed, and although they are not verified by affidavit, we think they are a sufficient compliance with the provisions of the Code to authorize an appeal. By the 103rd section of the 16lh Article, it is provided, that “it shall not be necessary for any defendant to make oath to his answer, unless required by the complainant.” The bill before us does not require the answers to be sworn to.

For the purpose of putting the cause at issue, and upon final hearing they are sufficient without oath. But, to sustain a motion for a dissolution of the injunction, it is necessary, under the latter clause of the 103rd section, 16th Article, that the answer should be sworn to, whether the oath be required by the bill or not. (Decided June 7th, 1860.) We consider tire charge of fraud in the bill all sufficient to show jurisdiction in equity; this is not a case of irreparable damage, in which the facts showing the damage are to be set out; it is a case of alleged fraud. We must, however, reverse the order because the claim of the complainants is not stated with sufficient distinctness, nor are there exhibits accompanying the bill to show that Lazier, or other complainants, are creditors of the defendant Mahaney. “Evidence of their alleged claims ought to have been produced to satisfy the conscience of chancery of their existence.” Union Bank of Maryland vs. Poultney & others, 8 Gill & Johns., 332, and Nausbaum & Bowes vs. Stein & others, 12 Md. Rep., 318 .

Order reversed with costs, and cause remanded.