Maryland case law › Marcus v. Montgomery County

Marcus v. Montgomery County

257 Md. 18 (1970) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Remanded✓ Good law
SummaryThe appellant, Marcus, sought to examine records of the maintenance division of Montgomery County's public works department for use in a damage suit he had filed against the County. He proceeded under Art. VIII, Sec. 3 of the County's charter, which had been repealed. The trial court denied the relief he sought, and he appealed. At argument before the Court of Appeals, the County admitted that it had resisted the appellant's petition on procedural grounds. Both parties conceded that the information the appellant sought—records concerning work done by the County on Henderson Avenue east of Georgia Avenue, including the shoulders, from January 1, 1965 to April 1, 1968; records concerning drainage and road conditions on Henderson Avenue east of Georgia Avenue from January 1, 1965 to January 1, 1969; and records concerning matters referred to in the County's Answers 1.(d)-(h) to appellant's
Questions presented
  • Whether the appellant was entitled to examine certain records of the maintenance division of Montgomery County's public works department under Art. VIII, Sec. 3 of the County's charter, which had been repealed, for use in a damage suit against the County.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. The appellant, endeavoring to examine certain records ■of the maintenance division of Montgomery County’s public works department, for use in a damage suit which he has filed against the County, chose to proceed under Art. VIII, Sec. 3 of the County’s charter which had been repealed. From an order denying him the relief which he sought, he took this appeal. 19 At argument before us, the County admitted that it had resisted the appellant’s petition on procedural grounds. Both parties conceded at the argument that the information which the appellant sought: records concerning work done by the County on Henderson Avenue east of Georgia Avenue, including the shoulders thereof, from January 1, 1965 to April 1, 1968; records concerning drainage and road conditions on Henderson Avenue east of Georgia Avenue, from January 1, 1965 to January 1, 1969; and records concerning the matters referred to in the County’s Answers l.(d)-(h) to appellant’s Request For Admission of Facts, could have been gained through depositions as permitted by Chapter 400 of the Rules, and particularly as provided by Rules 405 a 1 and 405 a 2 (b).

The case is hereby remanded, without affirmance or reversal, for such further proceedings as may be deemed appropriate. Each party to pay their own costs. Mandate to issue forthwith.