Maryland case law › Marvin v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

Marvin v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

212 Md. 634 (1957) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DeniedPrescott✓ Good law
SummarySamuel Marvin applied to the Maryland Court of Appeals for leave to appeal from the denial of a writ of habeas corpus by Judge Smith in the Circuit Court for Baltimore County. Marvin had been charged in the Criminal Court of Baltimore with unauthorized use of an automobile and arson. He pleaded guilty to unauthorized use and was sentenced to two years; on the same day he pleaded not guilty to arson, was tried without counsel, convicted, and sentenced to four years. The two-year sentence had been served. Marvin contended that he was denied counsel in his arson trial despite requesting legal assistance, and that this violated due process under the Federal Constitution and Article 21 of the Maryland Declaration of Rights. The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam opinion by Judge Prescott, held that the United States Constitution does not require a state to furnish counsel as a matter of right
Questions presented
  • Whether the petitioner was denied counsel in his arson trial, as he requested legal assistance but was not granted it by the trial judge, in violation of due process under the Federal Constitution.
  • Whether the denial of counsel violated Article 21 of the Maryland Declaration of Rights.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

635 Prescott, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. Samuel Marvin has applied to this Court for leave to appeal from the refusal of a writ of habeas corpus by Judge Smith in the Circuit Court for Baltimore County. The petitioner was charged in the Criminal Court of Baltimore with two offenses: 1. Unauthorized use of an automobile; and 2.

Arson He pleaded guilty to the unauthorized use charge and was sentenced to two years in the Maryland Penitentiary on March 18, 1954. On the same day, he pleaded not guilty to the arson charge; and upon his trial he was convicted and sentenced to four years in the Maryland Penitentiary by Judge Warnken. The two-year sentence for unauthorized use has been served. Pie contends that he was denied counsel in his arson trial, as he requested legal assistance but was not granted it by the trial judge.

He argues this was a denial of due process under the P'ederal Constitution and a violation of Article 21 of the Maryland Declaration of Rights. The petitioner was twenty-six years of age at the time of his trial and Judge Smith stated when denying his petition for a writ of habeas corpus, “Your past history indicates familiarity with the courts and court procedure”. The Constitution of the United States does not require a State to furnish counsel for a defendant in a criminal prosecution as a matter of right. In non-capital cases, the lack of counsel violates Federal Constitutional procedure only when it results in prejudice to the accused in denying him the essentials of justice.

The burden of proof of showing that the lack of counsel worked an unfairness upon him in his trial and resulted in his imprisonment is upon the petitioner. There is no attempt to meet this burden in the record. Dowling v. Warden, 211 Md. 645 , 127 A. 2d 136 ; Truelove v. Warden, 207 Md. 636 , 115 A. 2d 297 . Art. 21 of the Maryland Declaration of Rights does not require the appointment of counsel in a criminal case, but was 636 intended to do away with the rules which formerly prevented representation by counsel.

Raymond v. State, 192 Md. 602, 607 , 65 A. 2d 285 . Application denied with costs.